Session Start: Sat Feb 10 11:49:54 2007 Session Ident: #Nonprophets [11:49] * Now talking in #Nonprophets [11:49] * ChanServ sets mode: +ntr [11:49] * ChanServ changes topic to 'Tune in to the next LIVE Non-Prophets show, Saturday, February 10th, 2007! (POSSIBLY a show on the 23rd too!) at 3:00pm eastern (19:00 UTC) on http://www.nonprophetsradio.com, or visit the website for archived episodes. (Non-Prophets)' [11:49] * ChanServ sets mode: -ahoq Non-Prophets Non-Prophets Non-Prophets Non-Prophets [11:49] * ChanServ sets mode: +oq Non-Prophets Non-Prophets [11:50] -> *chanserv* topic #nonprophets Tune in to hear the Non-Prophets LIVE, today at 3pm eastern (19:00 UTC)! Visit http://www.nonprophetsradio.com for connection information! [11:50] * ChanServ changes topic to 'Tune in to hear the Non-Prophets LIVE, today at 3pm eastern (19:00 UTC)! Visit http://www.nonprophetsradio.com for connection information! (Non-Prophets)' [13:00] . [13:17] * ThinkFest has joined #Nonprophets [13:17] Good afternoon! [13:21] Hola [13:21] Mostly afk...getting stuff setup [13:22] Awrighty. I think da Jeff is flexing his hand and stuff. :) [13:23] * rudeboy has joined #Nonprophets [13:23] * rudeboy belches [13:23] damn.... backwash [13:27] 'allo! [13:27] Be there VERY soon. [13:28] * wwfsmd has joined #Nonprophets [13:28] * wwfsmd has quit IRC (wwfsmd) [13:30] * NPR_fanboy has joined #Nonprophets [13:30] * NPR_fanboy has quit IRC (NPR_fanboy) [13:31] jeeezuz fuckm NPR fanboy?!?!?! [13:31] what kind of messed up nick is that? [13:32] * NPR_fanboy has joined #Nonprophets [13:32] someone's puttin junk into the water again [13:33] Is the audio stream up yet? [13:33] hm let me check [13:33] yep it's up [13:33] just music right now [13:34] ya i cant even hear that [13:34] reload [13:34] or restart and reload, usually that clears up any minor glitches [13:35] i just had to tweak som mplayer settings [13:36] You sure that's the nick you want to use in here? [13:36] lol [13:36] i am one of your fanboys [13:36] but if you want me to change [13:37] * NPR_fanboy has quit IRC (Client exited) [13:37] We will not be held responsible for any mercilous teasing that might occur. :) [13:37] heh [13:37] 8) [13:39] * tux has joined #Nonprophets [13:39] Friar Tux? [13:40] no the linux mascot [13:40] ah [13:41] i need food [13:41] I need beer [13:41] Or I'll beerly make it through the day... [13:41] asshat [13:42] yes [13:42] * rudeboy races to the fridge for the prescribed beer [13:42] doctor said I should drink more [13:43] mmmm Milwaukee's BEst [13:44] Im only 16 [13:44] then it's coke for you kid [13:44] er.... coca cola [13:44] you guys are a bad example :) [13:45] lol [13:45] oh, the worst, or if I was a sausage, the wurst [13:45] * MikeHall has joined #Nonprophets [13:47] who saw the atheist bashing on cnn? [13:48] oh? when was this? [13:48] and who got bashed? [13:48] atheists in general [13:49] i think it was feb 1 cnn had a special about athiests being dicriminated against [13:49] It's been all over the net and we'll probably talk about it today - as we're pretty pissed [13:49] It was nothing new... the usual bollocks. "We're a Christian nation, etc" [13:49] I say we.. I'm in England. [13:49] And of course, no atheists to defend, right? [13:49] No [13:50] same old nonsense [13:50] well what made me mad was they said athiests should just shut up [13:50] One guy there saying "they have the right to their opinion" and everyone else saying "they need to shut up" [13:50] correct rude [13:50] And "freedom of religion doesn't mean freedom from religion" [13:50] That's Bill O reilly's favorite phrase, "shut up" [13:51] oh, here we go again with that Newt Gingrich crap, "freedom of doesn;t mean freedom from...." what a load [13:51] but i saw the clip on youtube and it has made me change my forensics speech to talk about just that [13:52] can you link that clip? [13:53] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fPHnXrU5JzU [13:54] thanks [13:55] what a fucking load of propaganda [13:55] Yes - the usual crap [13:55] * NeutronJack has joined #Nonprophets [13:55] NJ! [13:55] Lovely to see you, rudeboy! [13:56] they are all saying "we're a xtian country" that's fucking stupid' [13:56] oh, good, they have no PR rep or marketing [13:56] oh, we're just crying "wolf" [13:56] is the sound out or is it my computer again? [13:57] and "we" took prayer out of school [13:57] no, stream is up but no sound [13:57] ok i was worried [13:57] mplayer is a piece of junk [13:58] Tsk. And I hurried home from the store to listen.. and there is no sound hehe [13:58] her statistics are completely wrong [13:58] guys come on we cant infringe upon there "right" to make us do as they say [13:58] I've only ever listened via the podcast before, this is my first time listening live [13:58] same [13:58] welcome aboard [13:58] the fun starts in about 4 minutes [13:58] * NeutronJack is shivering with antici ... [13:59] pation! [13:59] that's just the malaria talking, NJ [13:59] i need to get my lines of coke set up incase they say ass hat [13:59] lol [13:59] We'll be starting the show a bit late...stay tuned. [13:59] don't forget the straws [13:59] We guessed :-) [13:59] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Prophets_Radio#Drinking_Game [13:59] (we're waiting on one fairly important individual) [13:59] the engineer? [13:59] There are no important individuals in this show! [14:00] That'd be pretty impossible [14:00] Doctor Who? [14:00] He's fairly important. [14:00] <---engineer. We do the show at my place and we wouldn't be chatting if I wasn't here. :) [14:00] Seven of Nine? [14:02] * Godless_Guitarist has joined #Nonprophets [14:02] hey, I'm a fucking genius, whadda ya want? [14:02] My IQ fluctuates with my consumption of alcohol [14:04] * slyprimate has joined #Nonprophets [14:04] ok [14:04] I wonder what the collective noun for a group of atheists would be... [14:05] don't ask those asshats on that CNN clip [14:05] * hey has joined #Nonprophets [14:05] We're hardly a herd. [14:05] I don;t think we're a gaggle either [14:05] A doubt of atheists? [14:05] clutch? [14:05] A mind of atheists? [14:05] * Victor has joined #Nonprophets [14:05] * hey has quit IRC (hey) [14:05] athiests tend to think for themselves so it would be a school (like in fish) because we have no true leader [14:06] * wwfsmd has joined #Nonprophets [14:06] a school of atheists sounds like a secular education facility though [14:06] but a graduate level of school [14:06] Where we are indoctrinated with atheist dogma! [14:06] or, if feline, catma [14:06] i just cant win [14:06] * Judas has joined #Nonprophets [14:07] A freethought of atheists? [14:07] I like that [14:07] it has a ring to it [14:07] here we go [14:07] Show! [14:07] hurray [14:08] * NeutronJack heard "doughnuts"! [14:08] * slyprimate has quit IRC (Connection reset by peer) [14:08] * tux is a computer geek [14:08] mouthfull of donuts? [14:08] hit that music cue [14:08] He was killed with a doughnut! [14:08] D'oh!! [14:08] * arensb has joined #Nonprophets [14:08] a deer,m a female deer [14:08] You see - you just don't get this kind of professionalism when you listen to the podcast hehe [14:09] the suspence adds to it all [14:09] I profess that may be true [14:09] but it adds to the informality [14:09] * NeutronJack dances [14:09] ah, never mind.... [14:10] * slyprimate has joined #Nonprophets [14:10] * tux is a god [14:10] * zippyapparition has joined #Nonprophets [14:10] That'll make me an a-tux-ist then [14:10] Most gods have worshippers other than themselves. [14:11] ya you cant prove im not a god [14:11] Proof by obviousness. [14:11] well, gawd damn it [14:11] jkjki [14:11] there, do your thing [14:12] forces of reality? [14:12] lol [14:12] Hooray! [14:12] brute? [14:12] o man [14:12] * Acer800 has joined #Nonprophets [14:12] anna nicole, there's a pair [14:12] i like debates [14:12] a dead pair [14:12] lol [14:12] pear [14:13] pears pural [14:13] jeeez, I need more beer [14:13] I thnk i hate you [14:13] rumour has it one of her breasts came from an ahteist [14:13] mmm mexican food.... [14:13] damn it now I'm hungry and thirsty too [14:13] * NeutronJack participates. [14:13] heh [14:13] shut up and drink your beer [14:13] darwin day [14:14] Some of you will say "and that's different from normal, how?" - but I'll probably be less active in chat than normal. Ya never know. If you need our attention for something - make it obvious. :) [14:14] woot! [14:14] I like that [14:15] who thinks i could talk my girlfriend into darwin day over v-day? [14:15] Best of luck with that. [14:16] try lots of chocolates [14:16] ill still get her candy and flowers but just 2 days early [14:17] * NeutronJack hasn't actually been "run out of a town". [14:17] I prefer Steak and Blow Job Day, myself. [14:17] lol [14:17] thats not gona happen [14:17] You don't like blow jobs? [14:17] Steak and blow job day, which day is that? [14:18] One month after Valentine's Day. [14:18] We vegetarians only celebrate half of that. [14:18] im 16 [14:18] veg-e-blow? [14:18] keep it clean [14:19] the clip at You Tube pretty much is self explanatory [14:19] hehe I love asking people if they have stopped beating their wife [14:19] They had NO intention of making that commentary fair to atheists [14:19] * ThinkFestMobile has joined #Nonprophets [14:19] Of course not, why would they? [14:20] g'day. [14:20] They hate atheists because we exist. [14:20] As far as they are concerned, it's like making a fair commentary on the Nazis [14:20] no they didnt i think they are going after the fox news people [14:21] debbie Schlussel cant use a search engine [14:21] It was SET UP [14:21] * GMP has joined #Nonprophets [14:21] she claims that there are no clips of the show on the net [14:21] Oh, and she called PZ Myers a "higher power" [14:21] I guess that makes me a theist, since I believe that PZ exists. [14:22] huh? [14:22] scienceblogs.com/pharyngula [14:22] * Useless has joined #Nonprophets [14:22] gee, snide little piece of shit is what she is, more so than the comment [14:22] "journalist" [14:23] MY ASS [14:23] she's an asshat [14:23] "I disagree with you." "That's HATE MAIL!!!" [14:23] huh? [14:23] muslim fundamentalists? [14:23] jeezuz, they let a nutcase like her on? [14:23] Yeah, she really wrote that. [14:23] europe is not becoming muslim [14:23] Is it fuck, [14:23] debbieschlussel.com check it out [14:23] Atheism--the gateway belief system. [14:24] lol [14:24] what a fucking load of bullshit [14:24] I'm in the UK - barely any muslims here [14:24] There _is_ an increase in muslims in Europe, but it has everything to do with immigration from Muslim countries. [14:24] yeah [14:24] but hardly "becoming" [14:24] heh [14:25] 2.7% Muslim population here [14:25] Where's here? [14:25] UK [14:26] * arensb bows down to PZ Myers. [14:26] * ThinkFestMobile has quit IRC (Ping timeout) [14:27] she's beyond a liar [14:27] islamic imposition? How SO? [14:27] Out of interest, 23.1% of people in the UK are atheist. [14:27] what the frig does that mean? [14:27] Look at Charles Darwin--he DIED! [14:27] :-) [14:27] * ThinkFest3 has joined #Nonprophets [14:27] heh [14:28] No! [14:28] More swearing! [14:28] They just show strong emotion [14:28] It's big and clever! [14:28] :-) [14:28] let's be fair while the other side continues to lie, cheat, propagandize... [14:29] there waqs nothing FAIR about that segment [14:29] Exactly, rudeboy. We're better than they are. [14:29] well, I know I am [14:29] I'd have come on with a beer in hand and a taco and yelled at the bitch, but that's just me [14:29] I'd eat half the taco and throw the other half at the bitch [14:29] they were in mississippi wernt they? [14:30] and chug the beer [14:30] the family that was ran out of time [14:30] How does she know it's atheism, and not Jewish fathers, that turns people into Muslim jihadists? [14:30] town* [14:30] * NeutronJack blames fluoridation. [14:31] * rudeboy blames air pollution [14:31] * arensb protects his precious bodily fluids. [14:31] because "thoughs who stand for nothing will fall for anything" [14:31] taints the precious bodily fluids [14:32] BRB [14:32] * arensb would love to see Dennett on CNN. [14:32] Dennett would be cool. :) [14:33] * arensb plugs Julia Sweeney's "Letting Go of God" [14:34] * NeutronJack has FOND memories of Anna Nichole. [14:35] what one was it? [14:36] I have two fond mamories of her... [14:36] * scarlett75 has joined #Nonprophets [14:36] BRB laundry time [14:36] I have absolutely no memories of her. [14:36] ah yes I remember them well [14:36] he said he had seen the stats - he just didn't believe them [14:37] hello [14:37] hi [14:37] hey scarlett [14:37] Gays and Jews have raised people's consciousness to the point where it's not socially acceptable to be homophobic or antisemitic in public. But it's still not considered impolite to bash atheists. [14:38] ..."girls of Christian parents" :-) [14:38] what is wrong with bashing atheists? [14:38] It's dumb. [14:38] Um... it's bigotry?> [14:39] I bash religions [14:39] I hope that was a rhetorical question Judas [14:39] atheism isn't a religion [14:39] I just don't want the laws to be biased toward anyone particular group [14:39] I know that [14:40] I couldn't care less what christians think of me [14:40] they are welcome to their opinion [14:40] * GMP has left #Nonprophets [14:40] what about a boss? [14:40] * GMP has joined #Nonprophets [14:40] First off, bashing 'the ideas' is different from bashing 'the people'. I bash goofy-ass beliefs. I don't bash Catholic people, Baptist people, etc. unless they specifically warrant it as individuals and I bash on what they've actually said and done as individuals. [14:40] Address the issue, not the person. [14:40] I agree with that [14:41] Bash 'atheism' all you like. That's debate. Bashing atheists is bigotry. [14:41] Call me isolated but I thought a Debbie Schlussel was some kinda gas station junk food sweet snack. [14:41] never said anything bad about an individual christian? [14:41] There, that's bashin' on 'an individual'. [14:43] i have never said anything bad about a chistion because they are a cristion [14:43] I have and do all the time [14:44] then you are also a bigot [14:44] Well then that makes you a bigot too, surely? [14:44] Pastor William? [14:44] Pedo William, yeah. [14:45] no i don't judge all christians the same [14:45] Y'know, if they weren't so stuck up on sex and got laid once in a while, maybe they wouldn't get into pedophilia and whatnot. [14:46] lol [14:46] oh brother [14:46] I think their beliefs are wrong and I have an idea that some idividuals becasue of the way they act deserve to be verbally bashed [14:47] he wants to win [14:47] Bashing someone because of the way they act is okay [14:47] they are free to have the same opinion of me [14:47] YOU GUYS, I DON'T MIND IF YOU TALK ABOUT IT. [14:47] Bashing someone because they are a Christian is wrong. [14:47] Judas, if you want to bash people or groups because of what they do or say or believe, that's fine. The problem is prejudice == pre-judgment. [14:47] IF THAT HELPS YOU [14:47] they want to win -- in any way and at any cost. that's why they lie, cheat, make shit up etc.' [14:47] Hi, scarlette. Talk about what...? You lost me. [14:48] Jeff when your foot is not just in your mouth but almost coming out your ass it is time to stop pushing it in farther [14:48] Prejudice is bad. Get to know people and hate them on an individual basis. [14:49] JEFF _ PLEASE MOVE ON AND STOP TALKING ABOUT THIS [14:49] * Victor has quit IRC (Chatzilla 0.9.77 [Firefox 2.0.0.1/2006120418]) [14:49] This is getting dull. [14:49] Ditto. [14:49] well you should tell the guys on the show to stop saying "christians" do do this and that and adress it to an individual [14:49] which would be ridiculous by the way [14:49] This is the law of the excluded middle, surely? [14:49] When they say "Christians do this," they're reporting *facts*. Not imagined prejudices. [14:50] I excluded my middle, I wouldn't be able to digest [14:50] making genERALIZATIONS IS WHAT WE DO HERE ALL THE TIME SURELY? [14:50] soory caps locked [14:50] Matt, Russell, Dennis - PLEASE GAG JEFF [14:51] This 'dichotomy' crap is going on and on and on and isn't going anywhere. [14:51] The three possibilities are "yes, I believe that", "no, I don't believe that", and "I don't know". [14:51] * slyprimate has left #Nonprophets [14:51] Maybe Jeff should get some formal training in logic [14:52] We're moving on :) [14:52] good [14:52] IT IS C!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [14:52] thanks. [14:52] I can recommend Introducing Logic by Dan Cryan [14:52] Jeff's point specifically is that there are situations in which there is a legitimate dichotomy, and he was backing off from the position in which he was being accused of the opposite of his position because in that case, he decided later, they were *right*. Anyways... [14:52] I think I will go read Debbie Sclussel [14:53] GMP: If you don't believe in an afterlife, save your precious life-seconds for something else. [14:54] I've managed to move my mom away from Deepak Chopra and Rush Limbaugh, and toward Daniel Dennett. [14:54] I was almost at the point than some of my precious life seconds would be better spent with the dumb blonde than with Jeff [14:54] Both my parents are atheist. And I got them both the God Delusion for Christmas hehe [14:54] lol [14:54] eh? she's a dead dumb blonde [14:55] schools come in flavors? [14:55] i got the school library to buy the book the god delusion [14:55] huh [14:55] arensb - get her a copy of the Julia Sweeney CD "Letting Go of God" - i gave 8 copies to people as xmas presents [14:55] good for you, tux [14:55] I'm looking at setting up a British atheist podcast at the moment [14:55] It's already lying by the door for the next time I go over to see $PARENTS. [14:55] i think im the only one who has checked it out though [14:55] Debbie Schlussel is a dumb blonde - typical Ann COulter right wing look alike [14:56] ah, that dumb blonde [14:56] so many dumb blondes [14:56] She's also a troll? [14:56] she's ann coulter with more meat on the skeleton [14:56] Hellbound Alleee is great - just for the music [14:56] ... and a troll [14:57] Somebody please write a book, "Okay, You're Over The God Crap. These Are Your Rewards" or "Ethical Stuff Atheists Do When Theists Aren't Wasting Their Time" ? [14:57] Hellbound Ali G? [14:57] http://www.hellboundalleee.com/ [14:57] "... wasting their time worrying about what atheists are doing." [14:58] Hurray! [14:58] * tux has quit IRC (tux) [14:58] you need to finish the sentence [14:58] * Dave63 has joined #Nonprophets [14:58] * tux has joined #Nonprophets [14:59] UK has state funded religious schools - Islam, Orthodix Judaism, etc - watch Dawkins series :The Root of all Evil" [14:59] Yeah, but the C of E is so boring, it turns people away from religioin. [15:00] I know - I went to a state funded Catholic School [15:00] So it leaves the fanatics as the only religious people in the coountry [15:00] The US has *fun* religions. With dancing and water slides and stuff. [15:00] and snakes and loud organs and pedo priests [15:00] Plus, they sent us all the religious nuts on the Mayflower. [15:00] "Cake or death?" [15:00] They cut themselves off from the rest of society - no one knows what is going on in those community [15:01] * arensb was just thinking of Eddie Izzard. [15:01] lol [15:01] what, did Izzard's cross dressing offend someone? [15:01] I think 'the fanatics' would be around 45% of the U.S., not some obscure minority. [15:01] We got into this national mess by assuming the crazies were rare. [15:01] * Mark has joined #Nonprophets [15:01] Oh, and Jeff's Scottish accent is terrible. [15:02] they are a minority, a vocal and well connected minority [15:02] No really, very very bad. [15:02] I missed an accent? An opportunity to drink!? [15:02] Jeff's Scottish accent is very very very bad [15:02] (Had a phone call). [15:02] Woot! That's me! [15:02] he forgot to drink enough scotch, is all. [15:03] But he thinks its great [15:03] hence the need for scotch [15:03] thats all that counts [15:04] skatje.com is an example of someone raised in an atheist household. [15:05] She's younger than you'd think, from reading her. [15:06] * arensb agrees wholeheartedly with Matt. [15:06] arensb....Skatje is great [15:06] Don't teach kids the "answers". Teach them how to find the answers. [15:07] Frank Zappa refused to raise his kids in any religion - he thought that was a decision they had to make for themselves [15:07] We WILL be running over today - in order to get the free will stuff in. :) [15:07] Haggard! [15:07] HAGGARD! [15:07] Cool, since I only just got here! [15:07] Teach them how to find the answers by underlining freethought in the dictionary! [15:07] Ted "Straight Boy" Haggard! [15:07] Yup. If you don't trust your kids to Do the Right Thing, you fail as a parent. [15:07] We're really talking about two kinds of people referred to by the same word. There's atheists who know nothing of concepts like critical thinking or comparative religions, and then there's atheists with more connection to the philosphies that show why it's sensible, and teach how to reason more effectively. [15:08] i too am 100% heterosexual [15:08] Haggard beat teh gay [15:08] "Church Offers Homosexual New Life In Closet" -- the Onion [15:08] lol [15:08] * tux has quit IRC (tux) [15:08] actually ,aybe only 99.52% or sp [15:08] * NeutronJack notes that Betty Boop does NOT count as a foreign accent for drinking game purposes. [15:08] fence sitting GMP [15:08] lol [15:08] Jed Smock? [15:08] * tux has joined #Nonprophets [15:08] smock smock smock [15:09] Brother Jed? [15:09] shmuck [15:09] at my age I just hope I can get it up without the use of pharmaceuticals [15:09] Jeeez, I missed out on all the fun when I was in college... oh so may years ago [15:09] the lord love that .48% of you [15:09] I hear ya on that one mate [15:09] god bless viagra [15:10] Students on campus also support smashing beercans on one's forehead. ;) [15:10] lol [15:10] I had one jeezuz freak try to run his number on me, but I slammed him to the curb [15:10] Jeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed! [15:10] Sounds like Tom Short, the campus preacher who pushed me to realize I was an atheist. [15:10] This is the URL for my (Russell's) play: http://apollowebworks.com/russell/samples/joel.html [15:10] PUT YOUR HAND ON THE RADIO, PUT YOUR FEET IN THE BATHTUB, FEEL THOSE DIVINE JUICES!!! [15:10] This is not assigned reading :) [15:10] huh? [15:11] for those too young - Fireside Theater reference [15:11] s/side/sign/ ? [15:11] no, I was "huh"ing something else [15:11] You mean all the time we thought it said 'Jesus' it meant 'juices'? DAMN ARAMAIC LACK OF VOWELS!!! [15:11] church inspires self loathing? [15:11] Russel: the man, the singer, and now ...the wordsmith [15:12] He's been the wordsmith for quite a while. :) [15:13] I know... but now he's like a legitimate artiste' [15:13] www.brojed.com [15:14] * aANKOo has joined #Nonprophets [15:14] that's his website, he is going to UT next week [15:14] brojed.com looks like a parked site. [15:15] The effective method of having fun with Jed is a big whiteboard and big markers. [15:15] sorry, http://www.brojed.org/ [15:15] Yeah, it looks like just a bunch of search results. [15:15] then give him a parking ticket; he's overstayed his welcome [15:15] Oh, yeah, now we're talking. [15:15] parking tickets...lol [15:15] "Are you here to listen to Brother Jed?" "Oh, yes. We're all minoring in Comparative Idiocy." [15:15] I am buffering about 10mins behind the show - so if I sound like a knob - that' s because I am! [15:16] mmmmmm... ministry fruit. [15:16] Are they talking about freewill yet? [15:16] 10 minutes? [15:16] Bro. Ted! [15:16] Ted "I'mNOTGAY" Haggard? [15:16] no he was cured in 3 weeks [15:16] Ted Haggard is now the pariah of Christianity...he came back from the gay [15:16] Right. Ted was just acting out? [15:17] He managed to act straight long enough to get out of the treatment. [15:17] what does that mean exactly? [15:17] Acting out!?!?! [15:17] and then besides the drugs [15:17] so...homosexuality is like...a tantrum? [15:17] which if it were anyone else, they'd have his xtian ass in prison right now [15:17] I think he means, "I'm not gay, I was just acting out. I was 'acting out fondling other men' and 'acting out anal sex with other men' and ''acting out fellatio of other men". But I'M NOT GAY." [15:17] ahhaha "The gay" [15:17] did they attach electrodes to his testicles? [15:18] MikeHall, it's spelled "teh gay" :-) [15:18] lol [15:18] Of course :) [15:18] gay camp [15:18] yikes [15:18] * Godless_Guitarist has quit IRC (Godless_Guitarist) [15:19] Hmm, so somewhere around his 750th male prostitute while he was on drugs, Ted Haggard sits up and goes, "Goodness. I'm not gay after all!" [15:19] cure me of hetorosexuality - my wife is driving me nuts [15:19] I like that now he's going to go get a faux phychology degree [15:19] Staying the hell away from meth forever is probably good advice. [15:19] your wife is driving your nuts? [15:20] not often enough! [15:20] It just took him three years of constant man-love to "discover" he was a heterosexual [15:20] do your nuts have a transmission and five on the floor? [15:20] so his gayness would wax and wain [15:20] lol [15:20] mostly wax it would seem [15:20] lol [15:20] one way to get ones wax [15:20] Brazillian wax [15:20] I bet Ted was crap in the sack [15:20] wax on, wax off [15:21] lol- rude [15:21] maybe i have been completely homosexual since last sunday - about an hour after the super bowl [15:21] can't hold a cabdle to that, eh? [15:21] i love the directness of the word "inserted" [15:21] candle [15:21] When will it turn out that Ray Comfort is gay? [15:21] SO...does that mean I've got my virginity back, since I haven't had sex in a week or so? [15:21] jeeezuz, my frigging fingers fumbled that joke [15:22] lol [15:22] oh bloew me [15:22] take how long you have been having sex [15:22] scarlett: That one works for me. [15:22] Wouldn't blowing Matt be a homosexual act? :-) [15:22] He just might if you ask nicely (and provide the meth) [15:22] and divide by 1 year times one month [15:22] Refloration for all! [15:22] :) [15:22] he's leaving town, just like the church moves their pedo priests around, and he's going to school to learn something [15:22] You didn't actually have sex, you were just... 'acting out'. [15:22] a MALE order university [15:22] LOL [15:23] yeah [15:23] ROFL [15:23] Hey, it's no worse than Kent Hovind's mail -order Ph.D. [15:23] YAY- reflowered [15:23] dissertation on INternet Pictures of Male Surfers [15:23] polish up that hymen [15:23] free will! [15:23] shit---we did I put that hymen polish [15:23] Scarlett - hope you get re-deflowered soon [15:23] ? [15:24] WWf they can't get to it before it is time to do it [15:24] No joke. I'll have to tell my husband that I got my virginity back.... hey- that means my kids were born of a virgin. [15:24] that would require freewill [15:24] SWEEEEET- i can start a religion [15:24] Because they were having too much fun with news and listener mail. [15:24] There is no free will but it doesnt make sense to live that way [15:24] watch for me to appear on tortillas and cheese sammiches [15:24] I'll follow that SCarlett [15:24] well, you do realize that xmas is the time for feeling Mary [15:24] let's get back to Ted Haggard - so many jokes left - or does our lack of free will force us to move on [15:24] * aANKOo has quit IRC (Chatzilla 0.9.76 [Firefox 2.0.0.1/2006120418]) [15:25] A couple weeks ago, a komodo dragon had some virgin-birth babies, by the way. [15:25] you are the best mother of a messiah - and I have followed a few [15:25] does that mean I have to raise the messiah's allowance? [15:25] probably [15:25] DOH! [15:26] sure - and we know your daughter is smart so I think if that like the first miricle [15:26] did not choose or did not give much thought about.... [15:26] damn...I'm never going to get her head through a sweater neck now [15:26] ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ......................... [15:26] hey she is the messiah - knit her a bigger sweater [15:26] her birthday is in three days... start your shopping guys [15:27] :) [15:27] Totally agree with all that. [15:27] How old is the Messiah? Hope less than 30 so she will not start preaching [15:27] Merry Possom-mas [15:27] 12 [15:27] Oh! Hello Possum-Progenitrix. [15:27] Happy Birthday Possum!! [15:28] Iesu started at 12, GMP. :D [15:28] * NeutronJack has quit IRC (Connection reset by peer) [15:28] ATHEISTS!!! are all you people godless heathen scum???? [15:28] I'll let her know later. Her holiness is at Target buying shoes [15:28] SOMEONE'S NEUTRONS GOT SPUN OFF [15:28] I will let you write your own card - you are far better at it than me! [15:28] yes - but his public ministry lasted from 30 to 33 - or probably just a story [15:29] I guess I should prepare the rest of my kids for getting the shaft in any famiy histories [15:29] I am not godless. I have a small dinosaur turd here that's named God. So when my government puts up that sign in the courthouse that says "IN GOD WE TRUST", I'll hold up the rock. [15:29] * NeutronJack has joined #Nonprophets [15:29] get ready for bad jokes about her getting nailed [15:29] ROFLOL [15:30] Quiet! You'll make her cross.... [15:30] *rim shot* [15:30] * GMP forgot to hit the breaks [15:30] watch those splinters [15:30] If she starts multiplying the goldfish... I'm out [15:30] sorry - was looking for a rim shot, not a crash [15:31] get her to multiply sushi and I'm there [15:31] (wahhh, my fishy died last week) [15:31] Ask her to bring Tarzan back to life, first. [15:31] Sorry, thinkfest [15:31] * Mark has quit IRC (Connection reset by peer) [15:32] but Turing was a HOMOSEXUAL - how can he be trusted? [15:32] S'alright, he had a pretty good life. I want another one now though. [15:32] the computer was gay? [15:32] Eliza.... Doolittle [15:32] It's based on the "Imitation Game", where you tried to fool partygoers into thinking that a man is a woman, and vice versa. [15:32] There is a fish-shaped hole in my fishtank as well as my heart. [15:32] pretty lousy life - he got locked up [15:32] I had Eliza [15:32] It was great [15:32] He was, poor Alan. [15:32] LOL [15:33] "there is something going on in my brain...." --- really? ;) [15:33] somethings happening there [15:33] what it is ain't exactly clear [15:33] :) [15:34] that song speaks volumes [15:34] and it's more than 40 years old [15:34] like me [15:34] how can you have COMPLETE control? [15:34] Oh...sorry- Matt got there [15:34] xians would like to return to 1952 when Turing was convicted of "gross acts of indecency", sent to jail, given hormone therapy and committed suicide in 1954 [15:34] Free will does not exist! What is WILL? How to you measure it? How can this "will" act to effect the physical world? [15:35] Most wills aren;t free. Lawyers usually charge for that service [15:35] maybe not free but relatively inexpensive will? [15:35] Dennett's book, subtitled "the forms of free will worth wanting" or something similar, starts from the definition of free will which most people *mean* when they use the words. Then he offers a definition that's more constructive. [15:35] There really ought to be three sides to this debate: "Free Will Exists", "Free will is BS", and "The free will debate is BS" [15:35] or fourth - define free will [15:35] so computer programs that can observe and regulate themselves have free will? [15:35] ThinkFest3: that was "Elbow Room: The Varieties of Free Will Worth Wanting". Recommended. [15:35] or like the republicans, we can't debate about what we can't debate [15:36] Things we do are done because electrical signals fire in our brains. It is not "will" which makes those electrical charges, it is physics. [15:36] *everone in Dillahunty studios is now backing slowly away from Russell [15:36] how far down the road of logical absurdity have we gone here? [15:36] I think it's most relevant to Atheism vs. Theism because "free will" is most often used in the context of God allegedly giving Humanity "free will" in the choice of whether or not to follow God. [15:36] first, DEFINE THE TERMS [15:36] about five bucks [15:36] LOL [15:36] $5 [15:37] $10 in Beverly Hills [15:37] Only if the choice really exists. If free will does not exist, choice does not exist [15:37] The most important thing I'd like to convey to the typical Christian person is that there are degrees of freedom. If someone says "Believe." and points a gun at your head, it's different from merely saying, "Believe." with no-gun. One situation is arguably offering more freedom than the other. [15:37] yep [15:37] When God says, "Believe." and then threatens you with eternal torture, it's arguably the smallest amount of freedom you could possibly offer in any choice conceivable. [15:38] yep [15:38] epiphenomenalism [15:38] I think what Matt just mentioned is a zombie, in philosophers' parlance. [15:38] there you go [15:38] conscious entity with the illusion of control: the LDS Church? [15:38] Mmmmm....donuts [15:38] What about an entity with the illusion of conciousness? [15:38] or the LSD church, an act of outer consciousnes [15:39] hehehe [15:39] the church of the glazed donut [15:39] I have found my LORD! [15:39] praise be the glazed donut [15:39] * rudeboy bows to the suger bowl [15:39] Carpe' Donut [15:40] Blessed be thy sugar and its pure cane goodness [15:40] "Illusion of control" is closer to the truth than most people (including me) feel comfortable with. [15:40] To argue that "will" exists, you have to first accept the premise that there's a meaningful distinction between what's "you" and what's "the rest of the universe". Like distinguishing colors, again, there can be a scale. But Denis is arguing that there's no such thing as will, and that's analogous to saying there's no such thing as orange because you can't tell orange from red. There really is such a thing as "orange", al [15:40] Blessed be the sprinkles [15:40] wow [15:40] *pregnant pause* [15:40] ThinkFest3: You've got a point. [15:40] There is a dscopnnect in there but I cannot codify it [15:41] If you cannot distinguish between two positions that can mean one of several things... [15:41] never minds [15:41] my brain is too diminished [15:41] I think all of us have to analyze our state of mind when we make decisions [15:42] It may only mean that you haven;t given it enough thought, or that there is no way to define the difference since it is next to impossible to measure [15:42] you don't even have to to straight to insanity [15:42] you might make different decisions when you're afraid or sad [15:42] We don't assume 'all insane people are 100% not responsible'. That simplicity is 100 years in the past. We now consider people more and less responsible, too. Mentally ill people aren't zombies, while everyone else is 100% considered responsible for their own actions. [15:42] THis is getting really esoteric... which means I need to drink more [15:42] your will might be bent to the emotion of the moment [15:42] thank you all - have to go [15:43] bye GMP [15:43] ah [15:43] Right, but insane people are locked up to be cured. Criminals are locked up to punish them. [15:43] * GMP has quit IRC (GMP) [15:43] no, Reagan released all of them. They roam the streets to this day [15:43] *snicker* [15:43] We have will, but it's not TOTALLY free [15:44] In Michigan, people are locked up for crimes, but sentenced to medical assistance, Arensb. [15:44] We have no will [15:44] I need to write my own will [15:44] both free will and conciousness are illusions [15:44] did you include me in it rude? [15:44] eh? oh, sure sure [15:44] ;) that's what I thought. [15:44] not much in my parlor though [15:45] They're not illusions, but they are are perceptual constructs. They'd be illusions if we could say they don't have meaningful expression or definition. [15:45] 3 snakes, a library of book on herpetology... [15:45] Hmmm...snakes huh? [15:45] a stereo, tv, and four computers [15:45] oh, and a junky old van [15:45] They are illusions in that they do not really exist. [15:45] Like, "purple" is a construct, but not an illusion. (Purple is perceived through a weird splitting of a chemical in the eye, unlike the way most other colors are perceived.) [15:45] is it a mini-van, rude? [15:45] yes [15:45] Woooot [15:45] They appear to us to exist, but they do not. [15:46] 91 Dodge caravan, burgundy red [15:46] We can verify that *what most people call "free will"* does exist. [15:46] * Acer800 has quit IRC [15:46] 219,000 miles on it [15:46] wow...that's an old school minivan [15:46] No we can't [15:46] YIKES [15:46] still runs [15:46] that's impressive [15:46] transmission is getting a bit dicey though [15:46] Had to rebuild it a few years ago [15:47] "free will" exists to the extent that the thing that takes inputs and directs the body's actions is inside a person's skin. [15:47] Sure we can. We get people together, show them stuff. If they consistently say, "Yes, that's it." and "No, that's not it." then we have something. Maybe the explanation for it is different than what we think, but it isn't an illusion. [15:47] WHen washed and waxed, it looks almost brand new though [15:47] :) [15:47] Here goes Russel with hte killing again! [15:47] They say "yes" and "no" because of the particular configuration of their brains at the time. [15:48] Yes. And that's the explanation for it. [15:48] But that isn't will [15:48] That's physics [15:48] What most people mean when they say "free will" is in contrast to what we do as a result of instinct. Not what we do in total. [15:49] think about falling in love [15:49] * NeutronJack is trying to construct a joke based on Ted Haggard, desires, and "root". [15:49] That's summation of the four fundamental forces acting withing the brain. [15:49] too easy [15:49] you really cant pick when or who it happens with [15:49] That'd be 'instinct', right...? [15:49] A choice only really exists if there was the possibilty you could pick the other option [15:50] I would argue that you never, ever, can make any other choice than the ones you believe you make [15:50] RISK [15:50] damn...monopoly [15:50] but you can overcome your own "programming" when you hit that "Eureka" moment in your life when you realize that something you thought was true wasn;t... [15:50] boring [15:50] could i choose to fall inlove with someone else? [15:50] We call "free will" all the stuff that's not undergone extensive processing. It really doesn't matter whether or not the processing is ultimately mechanistic, the fact is, we do think. [15:50] I think maybe the idea of free will means you can think outside of your own boundaires that were inculcated into you from a very young age [15:51] I could choose to be president but it will only be determined but what has happened in my past and capabilities etc - there is nothing free about it [15:51] There's a bunch of stuff we do that's "very" automatic. And there's stuff we do that's been extensively run through our reasoning, and we went through a process called "making a choice". [15:51] But "free will" as I would understand the term, means that I am able to make my own choices. [15:51] WHen the world becomes "a bigger place" than you realized, it does change perspective. Isn;t that really what we're talking about here? [15:51] I would argue that there is never a choice. [15:51] * Useless has quit IRC (Useless) [15:51] I agree mike [15:52] Then you've just reinvented the definition of "choice". I don't accept definitions that go against meaningful use of words. I think we all pretty much have a common concept of "making a choice". [15:52] but that's a game with an established set of rules [15:52] we only feel as though there are choices [15:52] You could only ever choose one option -- and that has been that way since the dawn of time. [15:52] Not necessarily, Mike. [15:52] heh [15:52] And if their math was good enough, someone would have been able to work out what that choice would have been. [15:52] you don't choose your heart to beat [15:52] Before it was made [15:52] If, at the very least, because we're constantly getting "new matter", there's limited causal connection to the dawn of time. [15:53] BRB laundry is screaming at me from the opposite side of the house [15:53] I desire to hunt someone down and castrate them for threatening my child... but, the desire not to go to jail overrides [15:53] that [15:53] Your laundry is screaming at you rude? Jeeeez, what do you do to your laundry? [15:53] Laundry - that is a terrible name for your wife - maybe that is why you are called rudeboy [15:54] Pregnant pause #2 [15:54] We might be robots, but we do things in two modes, reflexive/instinct and reasoned/choices. [15:54] #nonprophets [15:54] We treat people who don't possess sufficient amounts of the latter differently. [15:54] Bleah. [15:54] Nope, no choices :-) No reason. Reason is also an illusion. [15:54] Time is an illusion. Lunchtime doubly so. [15:54] No, illusion is an ill-chosen word which implies alot of absurd necessary conclusions. [15:55] Um... *tries to find a more useful word*... [15:55] Okay, the mouse cursor on your computer [15:55] Is an illusion of a mouse cursor [15:55] It isn't really a mouse cursor, it's computer software making something that appears to be one [15:56] When you break it down, break it down, break it down, the mouse cursor on your desktop is a load of binary [15:56] It's a perception, not an illusion. It has verifiable objective existence; it's reasonable to say "it exists" and ridiculous to say "it's not real". Illusion implies the wrong stuff... [15:56] Define illusion [15:56] Since no atom can speak, nothing made of atoms can speak. [15:57] Illusion would be, the actual explanation is different in a way that verifiably affects the phenomenon. [15:57] or desicions are the firing of nurons in responce to stimuli [15:57] From dictionary.com : something that deceives by producing a false or misleading impression of reality [15:57] The little gray splotches when you look at a grid of black squares is 'illusion'. You can break the illusion by looking up close without the black squares nearby, and it ceases to be visible. Choice doesn't vanish in a puff of logic when you examine it more closely; there's still such a thing outside of the context of a mechanistic universe or not. [15:58] like my mirror [15:58] The "impression of reality" we have says we can make choices. I would argue that this impression is deceptive. There is never a choice. [15:58] i think I am hot - but the mirror deceives me [15:58] so...the potential outcome is always changing then [15:59] Okay, I think Denis is arguing that free will is the ability to surprise God, someone who knows everything and has infinite computing power. [15:59] Let me give another analogy. We put sugar in our mouths and it "tastes" sweet. We happen to know that the reason this occurs is that molecules with a certain shape fit certain nerve receptor shapes on our tongues. That doesn't make "sweetness" an "illusion", it's just a more complex "perception" than we thought at first. [15:59] Yes, sweetness is an illusion [15:59] It doesn't really exist [16:00] but, thinkfest...not everyone perceives sweet as sweet [16:00] Now, if I cut your nerve at the microscopic level, and I send electricity to your brain so that you think you're tasting sugar, THAT would be "illusion". The actual explanation differs in a meaningful way from what we think is happening. [16:00] how do I know that my sweet is the same perception of your sweet [16:01] Yeah - and what we *think* is happening, is we are making a free choice. [16:01] * scarlett75 has quit IRC (Connection reset by peer) [16:01] * scarlett has joined #Nonprophets [16:01] What is *actually* happening, is we have no choice. [16:01] scarlett: much the same way I know most people mean roughly the same thing when we say "Free Will". We all get some sugar, and most people can say yes or no to its presence. But we also have good theories when someone doesn't perceive it . Cats, for example, have almost no sweet receptors. [16:01] my connection died [16:02] We all agree the Non Prophets is a great show - but we have no choice in it so don't get a big head [16:02] hehe [16:02] I just imposed my free will on my dryer. I'm making it work for me [16:03] Can't say I'm convinced by randomness either. [16:03] your dryer is submissive? ;) [16:03] passive submissive [16:03] My washer now, that's a different story [16:03] what is Laundry doing now - doesn't she listen to the show? [16:03] no your illusion of free will told you that you imposed your free wil on the dryer [16:03] if you slip it a dryer sheet every now-and-then, the dryer's self-esteem will improve. [16:03] No, I imposed my will, she had no choice' [16:03] Laundry just got it's ass kicked [16:03] *lol* :) [16:04] I beat my washer [16:04] lol [16:04] I kick mine... [16:04] pesky little slave [16:04] made of metal and hoses [16:04] metal and hoses...sounds like a fetish [16:04] hm [16:04] * rudeboy takes on ther persona of Squeezie MacFeelpants [16:04] gurgle [16:04] I'm still waiting for the washer/dryer that folds [16:05] Murder on the Orient Express :-) [16:05] My dryer fluffs [16:05] love metal and hoses [16:05] stop it there are kids here [16:05] no [16:05] Rude, your dryer needs to pursue a career in porn [16:05] I think that according to Denis, JFK was actually killed by The Big Bang. >:) [16:05] yeah, it should. I need more income in this household [16:05] lol [16:05] Hehe I'd agree [16:05] "hot spin" [16:06] my washer just agitates- ba dum bum [16:06] HOT SPIN, starring DRYER MACFLUFFnFOLD [16:06] rofl [16:06] *mutters* spin... spin... [16:06] He gives new meaning to "length of drying time" [16:06] best seller [16:06] lol [16:06] Alright, tis 10pm here and I have stuff to do. So I'll catch the end of the show on the Podcast. Great talking to you all! Bye bye [16:06] my washer can handle a big load. ;) [16:06] lol [16:06] night, MikeH. [16:07] night Mike [16:07] see ya Mike [16:07] by [16:07] * MikeHall has quit IRC (MikeHall) [16:07] I can here the music now as the repair man comes to the door [16:07] permanent press... Yeah, baby [16:07] hm [16:07] bye mike [16:07] cleaning the lint trap sounds extra dirty now [16:07] blowing it out sounds even worse [16:07] I wonder how I'd look in.... black nylons... [16:08] oh scarlett stop it you hussy [16:08] hey... I am a reborn virgin [16:08] I predict that you fail second-guessing the future! [16:08] I second guess the future all the time. Can't say I'm horribly wrong every time [16:08] was that an to too two? [16:08] I just realized something... None of us are heterosexual. We're gay and "acting out" this straightness. [16:09] I like how the guys giggle when they say "suck" [16:09] actually we are asexual and acting out sexuality [16:09] It's a guy thing [16:09] I am carving your idol now S [16:09] yeah [16:10] * NeutronJack doesn't think that he's had a single drink during this show! [16:10] I think he's distinguishing between fate and determinism. [16:10] I'm carving an idle.... a relaxed position sitting here in my chair [16:10] Neutron: they haven't said "asshat" this episode :-) [16:10] ASSHAT you muther.....ffff....... [16:10] no asshat? [16:10] heathen rude [16:10] denied [16:10] what i had my lines and straw ready [16:10] Also, I missed the scottish accent. :-( [16:10] I am heathen... heathen and seethen [16:10] (probably mispelled) [16:11] They mentioned it has Scandinavian origins. I was thinking, it's got special meaning for vikings wearing horned helmets. [16:11] Hey! [16:11] I'm a viking, watch it sony! [16:11] I just like to go around churches and pick up sticks on there lawn sundays. [16:11] thier [16:11] their [16:11] oops s [16:11] Why should Sony watch out? Are Vikings going to attack Japan? [16:11] lol [16:12] Are you in Denmark/Sweden/Norway/etc. or are you a Viking-American? [16:12] damn fingers just cannot type very well, damn it [16:12] damn farming hand fingers [16:12] Viking-American == Vinlander [16:12] Viking American [16:12] go back far enough in my ancestory, I probably had a viking predecessor [16:12] so I have lots of long distance cousins in Europe [16:13] yay - I am sitting out in the sun looking after my kids in their paddling pool go as long as you can! [16:13] if you go far enough back we are all cousins [16:13] I thought Vinlanders were, technically, Canadian? [16:13] Hey- the messiah is back...must be easter [16:14] (spinning... carding... carding... Oh! Wool! anybody here into spinning? I've got wool up for adoption.) [16:14] vinland was the name the vikings gave to a greener ploace than greenland [16:14] So Vinland is Norse for "greener land"? [16:14] and look where they ended up [16:14] Iceland [16:14] this is going nowhere [16:14] Land of vines, as in, grapevines. [16:15] That's the story anyway [16:15] is this the longest NP ever? [16:16] yup. [16:16] pregnant pause 3 [16:16] lol [16:16] I thought so, think [16:16] But they have found enough evidence of vikings to prove the point that they were her before Columbus, but then arguably, the native americans were already here first,, so... [16:16] it's like the Superbowl of NPs [16:16] (I started inventorying stuff because it didn't keep my hummingbird mind on it.) [16:16] Who brought the chips and dip? [16:16] where's the beer? [16:17] check that, I want some cabernet [16:17] In Birland? [16:17] where are the commercials? [16:17] where are the talking frogs [16:17] * arensb got a 16-pack of Guinness at Costco. [16:17] scarlett you have a lot of preganant pauses for a born again virgin [16:17] Non----proph------ets....snaps a fly [16:17] non Fits [16:17] well, if I can get to four pregnant pauses, then I've got my family [16:17] No, "paw-ses". :D [16:17] ah, the pause that pregnifies? [16:17] right now, we're short an Owen [16:18] I owen some money to someone somewhere [16:18] hey hey hey [16:18] we get to call him, "The O-man." That should endear him to the ladies someday [16:18] stretched it too far? [16:18] 4could one of you say asshat? [16:18] ASSHAT [16:19] i was talking to the prophets [16:19] They are locked in [16:19] * arensb drinks. [16:19] Tux I thought you were 16, you shouldn't be drinking [16:19] not that I am judging [16:20] Judas, did you just sell Tux for the silver? [16:20] that is for God to do [16:20] rudeboy gave me permission to do coke [16:20] YIKES [16:20] yes but I didn't get much [16:20] as long as it's cola, yes I did [16:20] ok - god bless then [16:20] I'm with Dennis...my brain just exploded [16:20] no i distinctly remember him telling me "it coke for you kid" [16:20] it's quite messy [16:20] Darwin bless me [16:21] * ouini has joined #Nonprophets [16:21] * cleans up after Scarletts explosion [16:21] eep! [16:21] thanks, Judas [16:21] brain matter [16:21] careful next time please S [16:21] rude...ask your washer if it can take grey matter out of curtains? [16:21] Mine usually goes off like Beaker in the Muppet Show [16:21] lol [16:22] yip yip yip yip [16:22] This is the problem with discussions of free will: it's a mish-mash of umpteen different subjects, and it's hard to unravel the different issues. [16:22] It's curtains for them curtains [16:22] * Dave63 has quit IRC (Downloaded the WikkedWire mIRC 1.3 at http://www.wikked.org/mIRC.exe) [16:22] Coit [16:22] Oddly, I don't really find it that difficult to unravel at all :) [16:22] argh laptop is running out of battery [16:22] My braion hurts [16:22] er [16:22] brain [16:22] No electric socket, Judas? [16:23] I hate it when my braion hurts [16:23] I'm perfectly happy with my compatablist position, utilitarian or not. [16:23] Good on ya, then. [16:23] and we love you for it, Matt [16:23] barion? a new particle? Do I get a Nobel? [16:23] I LIKE ANY POSITION...except missionary [16:23] or a No-Bell? [16:23] DOH! [16:23] Barionyx. New dinosaur. [16:23] I'll vote [16:23] It's the virgin talkin' [16:23] heh [16:23] party time gotta go [16:24] bye rude [16:24] back next time guys and gals [16:24] what number would that be on the table? [16:24] over and.... [16:24] * rudeboy has left #Nonprophets [16:24] bye rude [16:24] Guess laundry was shouting again [16:24] she is a pai in the ass [16:24] "I'm still talkin'" :-) [16:25] But we can tell apart what outcomes involved thinking and which didn't, Denis. So it's meaningful to treat them differently. The moment you claim that you *couldn't* and *didn't* think , that's when we view you as candidate for straight-jacket. :) [16:25] I was with Denis up to the point where he claims lacking ability control your own mind <=> mind control [16:25] * Judas has quit IRC (Judas) [16:25] Really doesn't matter if "thinking" is ultimately the result of cosmic particles and molecules interacting, or not. [16:25] some guy going "dooody dooody dooody" [16:25] :laughs. [16:25] Uh...oh. FUcking guys! [16:26] Is it raining men? [16:26] Hallelujah [16:26] im gona go take a hot shower ill get the rest on podcast [16:26] * tux has quit IRC (tux) [16:27] don't drop the soap, tux [16:27] ROFLOL- "Who cares about the guy?" [16:27] Coersion is always a transitive action, in my estimation. If there is no person/subject performing the action, it is not coersion. [16:27] * bnem has joined #Nonprophets [16:27] Coersion is manipulative [16:28] Does the universe have a game plan? [16:29] I think he is trying to say did we choose the basic desires when we are born. Are the desires malliable during a lifetime. [16:29] Nevertheless, I don't yet see how coersion is relevant to Denis' overall argument, or how coersion's not being relevant to your mind not being of your own free will, somehow undermines Denis' argument. [16:29] Yes, and yes. [16:29] It's not relevant. [16:29] Dennett does a good job of dissecting this. [16:30] I'd wish for a Dan Barker version of Dennett. With cute pictures. [16:30] "Programming", I don't think, is the perfect word for what creates your mind and its desires, but I dno't know that we have a word for a non-transitive programming of your brain which is beyond your control. I'm still with Denis, so far. [16:31] Coercision is bad I think malliablity of desires is the better track to go on. [16:31] Held to blame isn't the right words. [16:31] I don't lock up a criminal because I want to "blame" him. I lock him up because there's good probability that if something isn't done, he may do it again. [16:31] If you jump up, you'll fall down, simply due to the blind laws of the universe. But that's not coersion. [16:32] If the criminal was a Crime-commiting Robot, it would be blameless- its programmer is responsible, too- but it would still be locked up. [16:32] Right, coercion isn't a great word for it. [16:32] I am he who is known as I am..... [16:33] We're not trying to say there's something "wrong" with not having free will (as in 'subject to causality beyond your control'). We're not passing judgment on whether free will is good or bad. We're just trying to figure out whether there is in fact a simple causality controlling your actions. There is. Technically, Denis is right. [16:33] ThinkFest: what if the robot could be dissuaded from committing further crimes by being punished? [16:33] Good points, ThinkFest3. [16:33] He is right; the world's a very big molecule-machine. [16:33] Then we'd send it for counseling as opposed to impounding it,, 'cause it's a person? [16:34] Perhaps. [16:34] This is funny territory in the law today because we have a crime called "inciting" in some countries. [16:34] If it were easier than debugging it some other way. [16:35] "Our culture is not entirely stupid..." Damnation through faint praise. :) [16:36] It's getting ugly [16:36] Denis does not need to demonstrate that there is no free will. As a practical matter, there is a complete illusion of free will, as Matt says. But if Matt is claiming that there is a ghost in the machine ... that we are more than the matter that makes us ... then *he* has to show or demonstrate such a thing exists. [16:36] Denis's point under contention is that criminals don't have "blame". [16:36] That's not what I'm claiming [16:36] <-Matt [16:36] (I must have misunderstood your last point) [16:36] I don't think Matt is saying there's a ghost in the machine... [16:37] whoops, sorry Matt...didn't see your post in time [16:38] is it raining in Austin? [16:38] I think it's arbitrary the way we define 'orange' as separate from 'red' or "an adult is someone over 17 astronomical units of Earth time". There can be gray areas, but it's meaningful and useful to distinguish. [16:38] No, it's sunny and dry here. [16:38] I can hear rain...or someone's eating a PopTart and messing with the foil [16:38] ;) [16:38] That's Matt typing. [16:38] ahhhh [16:38] I type like... like a phantom. Muahahahaha! [16:39] Would it be fair to say that there is sliding scale of contraints one influence by our gene selection and the enviroment we live in? [16:39] These two need to get married...they remind me of my parents [16:39] Yeah. Denis's favorite example is that he hates cilantro. It's verifiably a genetic trait to perceive a really foul flavor in it (see ihatecilantro.com ). [16:39] Denis is actually arguing that we, as humans, *LACK* the ability to coerce our actions on a very basic level. I think that if, in the future, if we gain enough technology, we may be able to analyse and control our minds on such a quantum level, that we in fact can *gain* free wil. We just don't have such an understanding presently. [16:40] I'm not asserting a ghost in the machine. What I'm saying is that Dennis' position asserts that free will doesn't exist. I think that there's justification for an a prior acceptance of free will - just like there is for "I exist". However, that only gets so far. The point I was just making is that I have no way to distinguish between "free will" and the "illusion of free will" - Denis claims that he CAN make this distinction, and that free will is an illusion. [16:40] Just because there is no guy programming, or coercing, does not mean that we are, by default, that guy. [16:41] Denis doesn't accept the "layman" definition of Free Will; I kinda feel we have to until Dennett gets his way and instates the better one. [16:41] I'm in the position of "maybe there's free will, maybe it's an illusion - but with no way to distinguish, I'll stick with the utilitarian approach and act is if I do". Denis' position is that there's NOT free will, but we should act as if we do anyway. I don't think that he's made the case to support his assertion - and that there may be justification for thinking his position may also be wrong. [16:42] I agree; it's in the same basket as "solipsism" in that sense. [16:42] Spoken like a true compatibilist :-) [16:42] why would we act *as if* we had free will? [16:42] as opposed to what? [16:42] exactly [16:43] Agreed [16:43] I think he's saying that just because we can't presently make the distinction between free will and the illusion of free will, doesn't mean that it doesn't exist. In fact, it makes sense that it exists, but we can't control what we understand to be the underlying mechanical cause (coersion, programming) of our free will. [16:43] How would one act, if they were going to act as if they didn't have free will? It's not really an "argument", but it's certainly compelling... [16:44] Follow the Tao? [16:44] They'd go with their impulses, because they'd just say, "It wasn't me, it was the mechanistic universe manifesting through me." [16:44] Where this gets complicated is when my impulses lead me to second-guess myself. [16:44] Yes, agreed. It's terribly practical to act as if we are responsible for our actions. Pragmatically, there is no better way to act. But we can act one way, with the understanding that it is merely limitations of our technology and intelligence that prevents us from acting in an even "better" way. [16:45] These are kinda questions that were first visited when science pointed out that there's good reason to believe "thoughts" and "emotions" reside primarily in the brain. [16:45] Hofstadter has a new book coming out at some point, I think. [16:45] "I Am A Strange Loop" [16:45] Hofstadter spelled backwards is... Retdatsfoh! [16:46] I know I'm really far behind but the "no way to distinguish, but act as though there is" sounds a lot like Pascal's Wager [16:46] Arbitrary doesn't automatically mean "not valid". [16:46] Well put again, ThinkFest3. (I did miss the beginning of the argument, and can't wait for it to be posted ... ). [16:46] Possum#1 is sitting here listening and nodding---- I'm afraid. [16:46] Maybe he's frustrated that there wasn't something better? Like, I wish there was a better definition of "adult" we could apply fairly easily? [16:47] Hmm, now they're coming to the part of the argument I mentioned at the start. ;b [16:48] Intrinsic Blue...from the philosophical line of Crayola [16:48] "Free Will" is a useful approximation. "Blue" is a weak analogy. [16:48] A computer could be made to *have* free will I think. [16:48] Is this the abstract vs pratical [16:48] Heck, plenty of the programs I make do stuff I didn't want them to. [16:49] There's p-pause four [16:49] I'm good [16:49] answer your phon [16:49] e [16:50] Catch y'all on the legendary blogs! [16:50] see ya' think [16:51] Oooh, I like Matt's "Self-Awareness" statement. I still think, though, that though a necessary component, it is not sufficient to redefine what is useful (our common tendency of assigning free will, blame) as actual free will. [16:51] * NeutronJack did NOT ask for this. [16:51] LOL [16:51] You got the bonus plan :) [16:51] Though tense, I liked this episode. See y'all in a couple weeks. [16:51] Ok... I need to go back and catch the first thirty minutes of the show [16:51] Non-Prophets try Austrialian Broadcast Corp All in the Mind Podcast [16:52] -> *chanserv* topic #nonprophets Tune in to the next LIVE Non-Prophets show, Saturday, February 24th, 2007! at 3:00pm eastern (19:00 UTC) on http://www.nonprophetsradio.com, or visit the website for archived episodes. [16:52] * ChanServ changes topic to 'Tune in to the next LIVE Non-Prophets show, Saturday, February 24th, 2007! at 3:00pm eastern (19:00 UTC) on http://www.nonprophetsradio.com, or visit the website for archived episodes. (Non-Prophets)' [16:53] good show guys,... bye [16:53] * scarlett has left #Nonprophets [16:53] * wwfsmd has quit IRC (wwfsmd) [16:53] It is nice to argue like this and still be friends [16:54] * zippyapparition has quit IRC (zippyapparition) [16:54] later all [16:54] * bnem has quit IRC (bnem) [16:55] * NeutronJack has left #Nonprophets [16:56] bye bye! [16:56] * arensb waves and byes. [16:56] * arensb has quit IRC (arensb) [16:56] * ThinkFest3 has quit IRC (ThinkFest3) [16:56] * Disconnected Session Close: Sat Feb 10 16:56:53 2007