Session Start: Sat Aug 01 13:23:16 2009 Session Ident: #nonprophets [13:23] * Now talking in #nonprophets [13:23] * Topic is 'Tune in to hear the Non-Prophets LIVE, today at 3pm eastern! Visit http://www.nonprophetsradio.com for connection information!' [13:23] * Set by Non-Prophets on Sat Jul 18 13:45:56 [13:23] * ChanServ sets mode: +qo Non-Prophets Non-Prophets [13:24] -> *chanserv* topic #nonprophets Tune in to hear the Non-Prophets LIVE, today at 3pm eastern! Visit http://www.nonprophetsradio.com for connection information! [13:24] * ChanServ changes topic to 'Tune in to hear the Non-Prophets LIVE, today at 3pm eastern! Visit http://www.nonprophetsradio.com for connection information!' [13:25] * MikeA has joined #nonprophets [13:25] hello [13:25] I have a question [13:25] * Roland has joined #nonprophets [13:26] Fire away. If you don't ask, we can't answer. =) [13:26] I am thinking of starting a swim club here locally [13:27] do I or shold I be a non profit? [13:27] That's rather outside the bounds of the topic of the chatroom. =) [13:27] ok [13:27] * Freewriter has joined #nonprophets [13:27] sorry I guess I don't know what u discuss here [13:28] Check out the website www.nonprophets.org [13:28] Crap, got the wrong site. [13:28] thanks [13:28] That's sad of me. [13:28] http://www.nonprophetsradio.com/ [13:28] That's the one I meant. [13:31] Mind you, I can't see how a swim club would operate at an intentional profit, so if you have to manage money to cover expenses.... might be worth looking into what it would take for non-profit status. Session Start: Sat Aug 01 13:35:25 2009 Session Ident: #nonprophets [13:35] * Now talking in #nonprophets [13:35] * Topic is 'Tune in to hear the Non-Prophets LIVE, today at 3pm eastern! Visit http://www.nonprophetsradio.com for connection information!' [13:35] * Set by Non-Prophets on Sat Aug 01 14:27:55 [13:35] But everybody here seems awfully quiet except for certain smart-alecs. =) [13:35] * ChanServ sets mode: +qo Non-Prophets Non-Prophets [13:35] yay chanserv [13:35] * Non-Prophets sets mode: +o microbiologychick [13:35] poe control [13:36] * MikeA has quit IRC (Broken pipe) [13:36] -> *CodeWeaver* Do I know you from beyond the chat room? [13:37] Too darn quiet in here. [13:37] * CodeWeaver throws more packing peanuts. [13:37] Wait, that doesn't actually help. [13:37] Shh...we are trying to sleep. [13:38] * Owner has joined #nonprophets [13:38] * Freewriter has quit IRC (Connection reset by peer) [13:38] * Owner is now known as Rasputin [13:38] * Freewriter has joined #nonprophets [13:40] Setting up and waiting for folks to arrive. We'll have Kathleen, Denis and Thad. I'm not sure about Russell, yet [13:40] * jimbo has joined #nonprophets [13:40] ok [13:41] * ChristOnIce has joined #nonprophets [13:41] ChristOnIce: :) [13:41] * Non-Prophets sets mode: +o ChristOnIce [13:44] * ntesla has joined #nonprophets [13:46] * User has joined #nonprophets [13:46] * User has quit IRC (User) [13:46] * Robless has joined #nonprophets [13:46] * dwharder has joined #nonprophets [13:47] * dwharder has quit IRC (dwharder) [13:48] * Liei has quit IRC (Ping timeout) [13:48] * dwharder has joined #nonprophets [13:48] * helo_darqness has joined #nonprophets [13:48] test [13:49] why is nobody talking [13:49] nothing to say I guess [13:49] yeah [13:49] We're waiting with bated breath for the show. :) [13:49] * Echoman has joined #nonprophets [13:49] im making a YT video on if god has free will [13:49] not if we do [13:49] but if god does [13:49] my conclusion is that he does not [13:50] and therefore cannot be called god [13:50] dude, spoilers, not cool [13:50] huh? [13:50] thats the premise [13:50] nevermind, it was a joke [13:50] * dwharder has quit IRC (dwharder) [13:51] i really only have one point, i need more [13:51] but its that if life on earth is fine tuned, then life could only come into existence one way [13:51] Anybody connected to the stream? [13:51] Yup [13:51] why wouldnt god be able to create life in any way [13:51] * dwharder has joined #nonprophets [13:52] Oh crap, I seem to have another non-connection problem. [13:52] Every damned week. [13:52] so why would a god create rules where HIS creations can only be done rigifly [13:52] I am using vlc [13:52] so his own rules disallow him to do 'anything' [13:53] * stoooo has joined #nonprophets [13:53] * SgtHaile has joined #nonprophets [13:54] WOOO I got the stream back. [13:54] * smarties has joined #nonprophets [13:55] * konradius has joined #nonprophets [13:55] * Chappers has joined #nonprophets [13:55] I hear voices in my head! [13:55] They're saying lalalallalala goo goo ga ga! [13:55] * Chappers has quit IRC (Chappers) [13:56] I hear something that is very much not voices [13:56] * ShadowOfDoubt has joined #nonprophets [13:56] this is what my mother would call "noise" when i was 7 [13:56] not THIS [13:56] * PhilA has joined #nonprophets [13:56] * MSM287 has joined #nonprophets [13:57] Bread was good [13:57] * Lynnea_Dally has joined #nonprophets [13:57] yay BOC [13:57] * Lynnea_Dally is now known as EverythingElseAtheist [13:58] * MSM287 has quit IRC (MSM287) [13:58] * DorisES has joined #nonprophets [13:58] * mond has quit IRC (mond) [13:59] Non-Prophets: could we get some music for testing if the streams works? [13:59] Or just some of your fine singing? :p [14:00] * mond has joined #nonprophets [14:00] Hi ChristOnIce :) [14:00] Ho-hum - anyone else I know.. [14:00] * stoooo has quit IRC (stoooo) [14:01] * SpookyElectric has joined #nonprophets [14:01] * msm287 has joined #nonprophets [14:01] * stoooo has joined #nonprophets [14:02] * helo_darqness has quit IRC (helo_darqness) [14:02] * mond has quit IRC (mond) [14:02] * Liei has joined #nonprophets [14:02] * rudeboy has joined #nonprophets [14:02] I'm not getting audio on the stream -- are you? (I was a few minutes ago when they were testing) [14:02] does anyone hear the show, or are they not broadcasting just yet?... [14:02] streaming no audio [14:02] * mond has joined #nonprophets [14:02] so it's good [14:02] Here, too: the sound cut off five minutes ago, just as they were starting the music.. [14:02] * omnikinesis has joined #nonprophets [14:02] * helo_darqness has joined #nonprophets [14:03] * K_Nielsen has joined #nonprophets [14:03] gotta keep stats on how many shows have audio problems. [14:03] There's a slight bit of electronics noise on the stream.. [14:03] Greetings from Denmark ... [14:03] well, tell them to plug in the aux cable if they accidently unplugged it from the pirate transmitter, heh heh [14:03] ..and I know it's the stream, because there's nothing when my computer is turned off. [14:03] it's working [14:03] * Freewriter has left #nonprophets [14:03] K_Nielsen: way in front of you on that.. ;) [14:03] heres a question for you guys [14:03] why is it on AE, you list shows that never happened [14:03] greetings back to denmark [14:03] debdrup, heh heh, of course. :-) [14:03] * Freewriter has joined #nonprophets [14:03] rudeboy: why thank you :) [14:03] last week and 2 weeks before, the show is like 613: cancelled [14:04] Greetings from me, then. [14:04] greetings from norway :-) [14:04] then it didnt happen and the next show is 613 [14:04] maybe AE is doing a parody of the Bible? [14:04] whoa, land of my ancestors [14:04] xghosthunter: another Norwegian? [14:04] yes [14:04] me too [14:04] I seem to recall someone else being a regular in here that's Norwegian. [14:04] part nordic, part swede, part english (cough) [14:04] * kylind has joined #nonprophets [14:04] <- [14:04] joachim: why yes, you're the one. :p [14:05] did u guys hear VFX asked TF to a debate [14:05] * SubTachyon has joined #nonprophets [14:05] Helo: A long time ago, the tradition started that the shows were numbered by week, and it's never changed. [14:05] helo_darqness: no? Your source on that? [14:05] thanks MBC :) [14:05] can only stay a few minutes, have to go to work ... [14:05] Was http://www.palibandaily.com/2009/07/09/ireland-makes-blasphemy-illegal/ mentioned? [14:05] what do those acronyms mean? [14:05] * Aletheia has joined #nonprophets [14:05] SubTachyon: when? The show hasn't started yet. [14:05] microbiology chicl [14:05] chick* [14:05] Might want to leave that link for Matt in a query, SubTachyon. [14:06] * raynet has joined #nonprophets [14:06] Helo_darqness! [14:06] there's also this story: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/cornwall/8179635.stm [14:06] Another, perhaps more credible source is: http://www.independent.ie/national-news/libel-and-blasphemy-bill-passed-by-the-dail-1813479.html [14:06] yes, im here [14:06] blasphemy charges over nuded taken in church [14:06] are you calling me [14:07] *nudes [14:07] * DO5 has joined #nonprophets [14:07] LKL: I'm more curious as to why there were naked people in the Church.. [14:07] * DO5 has quit IRC (DO5) [14:07] artistic photoshoot [14:07] Starting...in a moment [14:07] its a sin to be naked? [14:07] celebratin' the naked lard? [14:07] helo_darqness, damn! [14:07] these photos: http://www.neolestat.com/neolestat_church.htm [14:08] its like on the simpsons..."if youre happy and you know it thats a sin" *clap clap* [14:08] hehe [14:08] If it wasn't for that damn serpent we'd all be happy in our nakedness. [14:08] i have a serpent [14:08] but we wouldn't know it! [14:08] and i am happy [14:08] * ville has joined #nonprophets [14:08] but are you naked? [14:08] right now... [14:09] I'm pantsless! [14:09] maaaaaybe [14:09] i fap to this show [14:09] music [14:09] Oh yeah, love that intro. [14:09] COWBELL [14:09] Oooh, don't fear the reaper! [14:09] they need more BOC [14:09] do they take song recommenddations? [14:09] theres a thread on iron chariots LKL [14:09] K_Nielsen: I don't. ;) [14:09] * Blahface has joined #nonprophets [14:09] ah. thanks [14:09] but i doubt they read it [14:09] oh [14:09] helo_darqness: they might. [14:09] but yes we have a suggestion thread [14:10] Yay, the Dennis intro is back. [14:10] =) [14:10] I doubt my pet snake would care if i was naked or not, just as long as he got his share of monthly mice .. [14:10] Anti-totalitarian, yay! [14:10] Noob question: how long till it starts? [14:10] SubTachyon: it has started. [14:10] ..just now. [14:10] noob answer: it has starte [14:10] Blue Oyster Cult is definitely non-sucky. [14:10] d [14:10] noob answer, yes [14:10] * Blahface has quit IRC (Blahface) [14:11] Completely or partially non-destructive? [14:11] fractally non-destructive [14:11] Hah, nice. [14:11] Non-introduction. [14:11] thats silly.....he gave instructions for how to listen to the stream [14:11] moar cowbell!!lol [14:11] Cowbell Hero! [14:11] Embrace the epic silly. :D [14:13] Max being Matts dog? [14:13] bird [14:13] Ah, his parrot? [14:13] indeed [14:13] helo_darqness: i'd guess most listeners aren't listening live [14:13] wow you guys are burning threadgills [14:13] ahhhh [14:14] darkflow? [14:14] how sexist. [14:15] its about periods [14:15] women only? [14:15] hilarious name [14:15] dark flow ftw? [14:15] ok, what would the name of the guy's group be? [14:15] whiteflow [14:15] lol [14:15] how clever [14:15] gotta go to work, bye all [14:16] bye rudeboy [14:16] Nocternal emmisions? [14:16] * Robless has left #nonprophets [14:16] * rudeboy has left #nonprophets [14:16] * Trybanpherto has joined #nonprophets [14:16] that sounds like a band! [14:16] * Liei has quit IRC (Ping timeout) [14:16] So anyway, I was watching the Simpsons and there was an episode where they were kinda atheist-bashing.. Even as an atheist, it made me laugh hard. [14:16] * Liei has joined #nonprophets [14:17] on a recent episode homer prayed by telling god to keep non existing [14:17] Simpsons is so long in the tooth. Let it die. [14:17] they made fun of cathlics [14:17] i watched it on hulu [14:17] mond: kinda, but there are fun bits from time to time. [14:17] first time ive seen in 4 or 5 years [14:17] it wasnt bad [14:17] debdrup: which ep? [14:18] helo_darqness: catholics! eek! ? [14:18] :) [14:18] joachim: think it was episode 5 of season 16 - it was definitely season 16 though. [14:18] or the other way around... [14:19] hello all, from a cool and damp corner of England [14:19] I like Nocturnal Emissions better.. [14:19] I find it offensive. [14:19] Find what offensive? [14:19] Someone should set up a stand at an environmental rally to ban nocturnal emissions, and see how many signatures they get on a petition. [14:20] women-only group? I hate being singled out as a woman [14:20] debdrup: what was the story, how were they atheist-bashing? [14:20] Ooh, Cathleen is getting saucy. [14:20] EEA, that's kind of the point. It prevents women from being the token [14:21] * eimerian has joined #nonprophets [14:21] joachim: just poking fun at atheists in general - but it made me laugh. [14:21] isn't it Kathleen? [14:21] joachim: true, it is. [14:21] Cathleen is a welcomed addition [14:21] is there something different about the thoughts / concerns of women atheists that justifies a women-only group? [14:21] But some women are not comfortable being around the typical "militant atheist guys" and wouldn't come otherwise [14:21] EverythingElseAtheist: welp, then make a group that's run by women but lets men join? :P [14:21] There are typical "militant atheist guys"? [14:21] There is still sexism in atheism and skepticism. [14:21] You, kind of an affirmative action program. [14:21] are you saying that men act a certain way? [14:22] segregation prevented blacks from being the token [14:22] as a typical male? [14:22] A lot of the men that are drawn to atheist groups do act a certain way. [14:22] What way is that? [14:22] SpookyElectric: geeky? :P [14:22] sexism in atheism? [14:22] yeah, what's wrong with geeky? [14:23] joachim: atheism is sexy. :p [14:23] sounds like you're about to say "new atheism" [14:23] Joachim, you're simply wrong. There were enough blacks to avoid that. All too often an ACA event will have one woman surrounded by ten guys [14:23] EverythingElseAtheist: nothing, as far as I know. [14:23] ChristOnIce: how many blacks attend your events, and how was i wrong? [14:23] i know, i love geeky. but even if i didn't, i would find segregation as a solution distasteful. [14:24] aren't there enough females to avoid tokenism - there are more than there are men [14:24] Segregation is a stepping stone. the women who might come to dark flow will eventually come to regular ACA events. [14:24] You were talking about historical segregation, not ACA segregation. If the ACA had a blacks-only event, we'd have to hope that both came. [14:24] hehe [14:25] but there seems to be an assumption that men must act geeky and women must act feminine and segregating out the "feminine" ladies will only force the men to be less feminine. [14:25] and disallow the geeky women to participate even more. [14:25] Not in ACA events, joachim. We have a fait number of active women in the group, but they show up less often. It is very common for only one to show up at something [14:25] gender roles are positive feedbacks [14:25] they self-enforce like crazy [14:26] The fact that a women's group has brought in members that other events have not indicates the need for it [14:26] Dark flow seems like a "necessary evil". Not ideal, but in practical terms it will draw more females to the group. [14:26] How is the evil aspect there? [14:26] Does anyone know where the name "Dark Flow" came from? [14:26] Bill Maher isn't atheist, is he? [14:26] I thought he was agnostic. [14:26] What does it have to do with a women's atheist group? [14:26] It would be no different than a senior group, teen group, etc [14:27] Bill Maher is a theist (and a twat) [14:27] i don't think Maher is an atheist [14:27] * jebus911 has joined #nonprophets [14:27] debdrup, Maher is just anti-religion [14:27] no, a men's group would be equal [14:27] raynet: yes, that's what I thought. [14:27] agreed. [14:28] Spooky- On the pub crawl, after a few pints, someone suggested calling it "The Flow" This was later altered to Dark Flow (an event in astronomy) [14:28] Matt Dillahunty for Richard Dawkins!!!! [14:28] Aite, cool. [14:28] * award [14:29] Joachim, a men's group would also be equal, but less necessary. It is this way will all minority groups. There is rarely any reason to have a special group for 70 percent of members [14:29] ChristOnIce - Any clue when you'll be back if ever? [14:29] what is thethere seems to be an assumption that the men won't be able to keep it in their pants and not hit on the females? I feel like the females are opting for a social burqa by forming a hiding away from the men group. [14:29] ChristOnIce: yup [14:29] omnikinesis: sorta-kinda. He'd have to do it as a representative of ACA though, because it's the ACA that does everything - Matt just takes the time to do some of the stuff. [14:29] Hopefully in a year or two [14:30] i hate people assuming that women just love and get along with other women and share some sort of connection automatically. [14:30] EEA: It isn't an assumption. It has happened in numerous atheist groups. [14:30] debdrup- true very true [14:30] aatheist. [14:30] ChristOnIce: would look forward to having you back [14:30] No one makes any ACA women go to the dark flow. It is there as an option if a woman feels she needs it. [14:31] I feel that it's an endorsement of a backwards way of thinking. [14:31] It's not as if the men are lecherous asses (aside from a couple). It's the absence of someone to relate to, and the overfocus on them (mostly for being new, partially for being a woman) [14:31] joachim: well, they might have ChristOnIce on through skype or through the phone-connector on during his non-non-prophetting. [14:31] why do you assume that women can only relate to women? [14:31] Hardly. If women within the group have a shared interest and would like to get together, it makes sense [14:31] Maher has been for HPV vaccine, but that's just because the fundies hate it [14:31] EverythingElseAtheist: but men certainly don't understand women.. :P :P [14:32] ..at least sometimes I think that's the case for me. [14:32] Nobody suggests that women can only relate to women. [14:32] do you understand men? [14:32] joachim: good point. No, I don't. [14:32] :) [14:32] So what have we learn't: I don't understand people. [14:32] people are idiots [14:32] Agreed. [14:32] The point is that they do relate to women, and often do so slightly differently. Very often, active women in the group would want to see other women with whom they're friends. This makes it easier [14:32] i do understand men, I feel the mystery of men / women is far overblown. [14:32] It doesn't assume that women can only relate to women. It is simply there because there is evidence that some women have issues that they are more comfortable discussing with other women. [14:33] EEA, I think you are right on that point [14:33] However, there is nothing wrong with recognizing shared interests and accommodating them [14:33] then they should form their own personal get-togethers, not ACA endorsed events. [14:34] Why does it matter if it is ACA associated? [14:34] if they really can't function 100% around men. [14:34] What's wrong with it being ACA endorsed? Should they just have to hope that other women hear about the group without the aid of the ACA? [14:34] It's not about them being able to function, it's about a change of pace [14:35] once again, the assumption that women won't want to come to ACA for its own merits? Do women only want to be atheist activists if they can be in a girl-only situation? [14:35] it's ACA endorsed sexual discrimination. [14:35] change of pace? [14:35] I want an atheist pope... more rightly, a pope in the vatican thats an atheist. [14:35] It is that some women are more comfortable not being the only woman around. It is intimidating for some [14:35] why can't men engage in a change of pace? [14:36] Lots of people aren't comfortable with atheism in general. When you also have sexism issues, some women need a safe space. [14:36] EEA, it is discrimination, but discrimination isn't always bad. If we had enough kids for a Teen event, would that be harmful? [14:36] if the ACA wants to have like an event that's a sewing circle, and mostly females come but some males come, there is no discrimination. [14:37] but if the circle is only available to women, then it's discrimination. [14:37] Again, you are implying that discrimination is inherently bad [14:37] The ACA is entirely a discriminatory organization [14:37] unwarrented. discrimination based on a physical feature. that is bad. [14:37] teens have different interests from adults [14:37] Had Phil Plait received the Richard Dawkins award? [14:37] scientifically verified [14:37] discrimination based on interests or intelligence: fine! [14:38] If not, he should. [14:38] * stoooo has quit IRC (Goodbye) [14:38] No, it is discrimination based on interests, just as joachim pointed out. The women in the group have different shared interests [14:38] Age is a physical feature. What about a teen group or senior group? [14:38] they can have what they consider feminine events, where mostly females come, then that's fine. [14:38] But they can't do that without barring men [14:38] ChristOnIce: and none of the men share those interests? [14:38] I almost hope he says that.. [14:38] So the women who want to hang with other women should hide behind a knitting group? [14:38] I can't use a womans public rest room. Is that discrimination or a question of practical comfort for most people concerned? [14:38] ..just because I like to see chaos. :p [14:39] wait [14:39] painted myself into a corner [14:39] ignore that [14:39] :P [14:39] The men, by and large, have no shared interests that are not met by other meetings [14:39] Women do [14:39] I enjoy going to normal events. I don't see why the other women don't. [14:39] Most of them do, EEA [14:39] EverythingElseAtheist: because women don't make sense? :P [14:39] Just because you don't doesn't mean it isn't needed. [14:40] Its not a split group. They like ACA events, but sometimes they want to hang out with female friends. [14:40] * Freewriter has quit IRC (Ping timeout) [14:40] the sorts of people who want to segregate themselves from others because of their physical features, then yes. I don't understand that sort of anti-egalitariansim. [14:40] then if they want to hang out with females friends, do that in their own time. [14:40] equalising requires measures that are applied unequally [14:40] EEA, you're simplifying this issue to all hell and ignoring the facts [14:40] They are doing it in their own time, they are just setting it up as a group. [14:41] Wait.. Bill Maher is anti-vaccine? [14:41] a group that the ACA should not support. [14:41] Why not? [14:41] bill maher might just be retarded [14:41] How does the Dark Flow conflict with the ACA? [14:41] Sounds to me like AAI just didn't do the research required on Bill Maher. Straight up incompetence? [14:41] the dark flow is their own time. It is only loosely related to the ACA. [14:41] So they shouldnt go out and support Gay Rights at the Pride Festival either? [14:41] joachim: true. [14:41] because it discriminates against a physical feature. [14:41] * DO5 has joined #nonprophets [14:41] So, EEA, you would oppose a teen group? [14:42] EEA: are you saying men can't be women? [14:42] What interest(s) do females have that isn't met by other groups? (and I'm a female and don't get it) [14:42] they should support gay rights, but should they have separate gay groups? or straight groups? [14:42] if they feel like women? [14:42] * DO5 has left #nonprophets [14:42] if they feel like women, then they are [14:42] so what's with the physical features? [14:43] Someone needs a pop-filter. [14:43] You are quite stuck on the physical features, which is just stupid. The Dark Flow doesn't exist because some members have ovaries. It exists because sexual differences lead to different interests [14:43] it's exactly saying that men who consider themselves women wouldn't be allowed into the group. [14:43] WHAT.. [14:43] What what what what what. [14:43] t*the group is saying that. [14:43] Wow, that might just have been the most idiotic sentence I've ever heard. [14:44] what?!? i'm a female and feel that the groups that are coed are just fine, no need for anything more...what am i missing? [14:44] Okay, that just suppassed it. [14:44] There are no limits to idiocy. [14:44] Aietheia. Do you have female friends? [14:44] yep [14:44] exactly! coed is fine. if you want something else then make it on your own time. [14:44] Do you ever want to just hang out with some girlfriends? [14:45] nope! [14:45] Oh no he didn't. [14:45] Alethia: When a woman shows up to happy hour and is the only woman, she might not come back. When some women get hit on all the time, they won't come back. [14:45] Do you acknowledge that many women do? [14:45] He didn't invoke Hitler.. [14:45] * ihedenius has joined #nonprophets [14:45] MBC, women don't come to happy hour and get hit on all the time [14:45] For one, Keith isn't there [14:46] Well, but it has happened [14:46] oh, happy hour? as a teetotaler, I personally don't go to happyhour, so i have no idea. [14:46] i suppose they must [14:47] A woman may have been hit on once, but I've never seen any repetitive behavior of that nature aside from situations where it's good-natured (a friend we've known for some time) [14:47] Funnily enough, the Mensa-level is now 130 instead of 140. [14:47] ...yet I'm still a member of Mensa. [14:47] I like to be one of the guys too, but some women don't or don't like it when that is their first experience with the group. These women could be an asset to the group once they are comfortable. [14:47] I've been to every happy hour until recently, and I have to say that women who come are much more likely to return than any other group [14:47] i guess i'm just not the bar-going type in the 1st place [14:48] It's very rare that women don't return (at least with happy hour) [14:48] women who come are much more likely to return to my place as well [14:48] do women not come back at the same rate as men who dont come back? [14:48] or are you just making assumptions? [14:48] This isn't for women who don't like other ACA events. Its for women who want something more [14:48] * shane has joined #nonprophets [14:48] My group is a sausagefest and I find that I need to specifically support women who come or I might not see them again. [14:49] * john has joined #nonprophets [14:49] hey not fair matt stating my position, no way he'd give it a fair shake! [14:49] Wow, sausage-fest. [14:49] * Pombolo has joined #nonprophets [14:49] what's wrong with a suasagefest? why the anti-male? [14:49] *anti-male terminology [14:50] haha, that's what i say! [14:50] Shit, missed 50 mins [14:50] sausage-fest is anti-male? [14:50] * evidelogiceason has joined #nonprophets [14:50] i don't think i've heard a non-male even use the term [14:50] But girls, Matt's already taken. [14:50] (it sounds nice to me, but has been used negatively as a reason why people won't want to gome) [14:50] *to come [14:50] debdrup: girls and special boys, mind you :) [14:51] joachim: huh? [14:51] Like it or not, EEA, there are differences between men and women. A large portion is due to socialization, obviously, but differences are there. Most people relate to men and women slightly differently [14:51] debdrup: boys might be interested as well [14:51] joachim: true, but I don't think Matt is. [14:51] To not have that inclination yourself is fine, to refuse to acknowledge that others do is silly [14:51] maybe the women should show up to ACA events wearing a burqa so the men won't hit on them, Matt? [14:51] like he isn't interested in most girls, eh [14:52] EEA: you trollin'? [14:52] EEA - stop acting like the knight in shining armour. [14:52] Women don't need you to defend them [14:52] I'm a female. [14:52] Ahhh [14:52] then you are just as arrogant [14:52] i don't care, i just like knowing the reasons behind things [14:52] glad you don't discriminate by sex pombolo. [14:52] Bra & panty pillowfights, obviously [14:53] b/c i don't understand it personally [14:53] ChristOnIce: only if there are pictures. [14:53] ugh [14:53] You're welcome [14:53] Francis Collins [14:53] What's he done now? [14:53] oh Francis Collins [14:53] dunno. gonna be pretty dumb though [14:54] being an idiot, as usual? [14:54] * shane has quit IRC (CGI:IRC (Ping timeout)) [14:54] Ah. He's good at that. [14:54] * evidelogiceason has quit IRC (evidelogiceason) [14:54] *facepalm* [14:54] Shellgame, yay. [14:54] Dear oh dear [14:54] oh it gets more facepalm worthy [14:54] * shane has joined #nonprophets [14:54] just wait [14:54] Can't wait. [14:54] *headdesk* [14:54] are they reading his lecture? [14:55] yes [14:55] slides from a lecture at berkley [14:55] This is just a shellgame... [14:55] great stuff [14:55] He's pulling it out of his ass. [14:55] Indeed. [14:55] Literally, he took poo and wiped it on paper. [14:55] Assert yourself silly! [14:55] directed evolution makes god an asshat [14:55] Couldn't have come up with this in any other way. [14:56] So I guess Richard Dawkins will be murdering babies any minute now [14:56] Aw, stream keeps dying on me. [14:56] shane: oh, didn't you get the atheist mail from the mailing list? We all have to murder babies now, our pope says so. [14:56] Intuition + REALLY strong feelings = God dunnit? [14:57] You also need to loosely base it on the bible. [14:57] Try the backup stream http://66.228.123.40:8000/listen.pls [14:57] Thanks. [14:57] AH! how long since they sent the mail! I have seen plenty of babies lately! so many chances to impress the pope! [14:57] I beg to differ.. [14:57] wasted! [14:57] It's very logical to me. [14:58] shane: yeah, it was sent a few hours ago. [14:58] I am so sick of hearing fine tuning [14:58] oh good [14:58] The constants are not fine tuned... [14:58] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Family_(Christian_political_organization) [14:58] Who comes up with this crap... [14:58] dwharder: stupid people. [14:58] How can you say somethihng is tuned when you can't demonstrate it could be something else [14:58] "if anything was different, things would not be like this" [14:58] ergo god [14:58] shane: because 'god did it'.. [14:58] In his book, he only says approximately 14 billion years ago... [14:58] shane: Dawkins will pick you up in his talons, swoop his demon wings over a nursery and release you, crying "Fly my pretties, fly!" [14:58] I guess he's adding one more digit to make it sound more plausible... [14:59] i don't know crap ergo god [14:59] dwharder: well, it's between 13 and 14 billion years. We don't know exactly yet. [14:59] omnikinesis: yes, yes exactly. That wraps up belief nicely. [14:59] ok well Francis Collins talk was fine tuned to make me laugh [14:59] Yes, but by adding more decimal digits, it sounds more precise and exact... [14:59] dwharder: doesn't make it right. [15:00] No, just makes you sound smarter: "15.3253% of Americans are athiests" sounds so much more precise than using an honest number of digits... [15:00] it is more precise [15:01] Because why would anyone make up those extra digits? [15:01] how improbable it is that he used the exact combination of idiotic ideas that stimulated the parts of my brains that cause me to laugh. If even on idea was based in logic I wouldn't have laughed as hard, or possibly not at all...... [15:01] woo [15:01] woo [15:01] woo [15:01] why did he need to do it naturally and then lie about it? [15:01] shane - God wanted you to be filled with laughter, obviously. [15:02] sounds like he's just grabbing credit [15:02] so he violated collins free will to make him an idipot so I would laugh? [15:02] RUSSELL== would you oppose the appointment of PZ Meyers based on his evangelism? [15:02] Last week, I asked my brother, who gave me that book "The Language of God" , if he actually believed any of the crap and would base his beliefs on it... Haven't heard back from him, yet. [15:03] shane - No he designed everything 14 billion years ago to come to a point where a person name Francis Collins were born and that he would make you laugh, again obviously. [15:03] COI - define evangelism [15:03] I'm using it loosely, obviously. Avid promotion of a particular worldview [15:03] Wow - you've loosened it so that it includes PZ in advance. How clever [15:04] damnit! spooky electric how can I argue with that [15:04] what have I don'e [15:04] ! [15:04] I have a feeling that if PZ were nominated for a federal position, Russell would give him the benefit of the doubt to separate his atheistic message from his official position [15:04] there is a god [15:04] shane - see god exists, its easy [15:04] omg I'm screwed [15:04] I gotta turn this off now before I do more damage [15:04] COI - if it was a science job, there is no problem. And there IS NO atheistic world view which can be foisted on people [15:04] what worldview is PZ promoting? [15:04] is he saying there is no god? [15:05] and is he claiming science supports his claim? [15:05] would be my questions [15:05] Have you ever read his blog or heard him speak? Have you not noticed comments that would be problematic in a governmental position? [15:06] yes x 3 [15:06] yes [15:06] doesn't answer my questions [15:06] * konradius has quit IRC (ChatZilla 0.9.85 [Firefox 3.5.1/20090715094852]) [15:06] I agree with PZ most of the time. I would trust him to take an office appropriately. I just think that Russell is skeptical of Collins on this because he disagrees with him [15:06] I would be happy making problematic comments in advance of a position. The point is, the problem arises if I get the job and THEN keep making them [15:06] Exactly, Pom [15:06] You may have a poit about Russell [15:07] *point [15:07] russell is often operating with two sets of standards [15:07] (imho) [15:07] * Pombolo nods [15:07] I disagree with Collins on some things, but I don't assume that he can't separate his personal views [15:07] Mommy and daddy aren't fighting, they're just having a disagreement. [15:08] i do, because he did [15:08] i agree with matt [15:08] I gotta agree with Matt too. [15:09] what did matt say? :) [15:09] Newton was able to be a Christian, and yet he was able to start something... [15:09] newton was fucking crazy [15:09] Matt makes sense [15:09] my problem hear is that the head of the NIH isnt a scientist its an executive and a figurehead [15:09] and his christianity halted his research [15:09] Matt is completely and uterly melting their faces :P [15:09] that there is no reasonn to assume collins will let his religion interfere with his science,as it has never happened before [15:10] And not just any science. The science that would actually confront his religious convictions. [15:11] I didn't even realise Thad was there [15:11] He's always quiet. [15:11] What would actually happen if he takes the job, and ends up evangelizing god, etc.? [15:11] Missed the first 50 mins [15:12] well then we could object [15:12] but its unfair to assume it [15:12] Isn't it the default position that anyone is innocent until proven guilty? [15:12] exactly [15:12] Exactly [15:12] actually, him being a christian could be a problem [15:13] ... would the damage be done, or can he be replaced again easily? [15:13] i'm not sure what the position is about, but let's say emergencies [15:13] he could be replaced on a whim i think [15:13] Then the problem would manifest through his ability to do the job... and by definition you then have a reason to remove him [15:13] (Him being Christian) [15:14] Non-Prophets: http://discovermagazine.com/2007/feb/interview-francis-collins "A devoted Christian, Collins defends evolution and embryonic stem cell research in his new book, The Language of God: A Scientist Presents Evidence for Belief (Free Press, 2006).". [15:14] He's for stem-cell research. [15:14] i think that's he's innocent until proven guilty [15:14] yeah, it would be unfair to punish him in advance [15:14] give him a shot and if he screws it up [15:14] then we will deal with it [15:14] hes not on trial... no ones sending him to jail [15:14] if i believed to be true that christian prayer worked against disease, it would make sense to prioritizing vaccinating other groups [15:15] * TheLiquidLight has joined #nonprophets [15:15] What? [15:15] no one is saying he is [15:15] I mean being punished by not getting a job he is qualified for [15:15] The key word there, joachim, is "believed" [15:15] then guilt or innocese is red herring [15:15] he doesn't believe prayer works? [15:16] I doesn [15:16] t matter [15:16] lol [15:16] it was a figure of speechj [15:16] ok [15:16] he isn't a bad scientist until proven to be so [15:16] jeez [15:16] if i belied it to be true, aka held it as true, i would be an idiot not to act on it [15:16] On pages 248 and 249 he discusses adult stem cell research as being hopeful; however, then he goes on and to say [15:16] is has been proven to have evangligal beliefs [15:16] Or someone who could separate beliefs from your job [15:17] "If one believes unequivocally that life beings at conception...then this would be an unacceptable form of research or medical care." [15:17] one " ... PROBLEM ... " is the propaganda value ... [15:17] he has seperated his evabgelism rom his science [15:17] so far [15:17] belief is a vague term [15:17] i don't really get it [15:17] sorry for the typos [15:18] he's convinced jesus is real and christian prayer works, right? [15:18] he has said [15:18] but this isnt a scientific post... its an executive post... his science is nearly inconsiquintail [15:18] for him, it has to be true [15:18] Ha [15:18] how as that different from the reality as he experiences it? [15:18] that his beliefs in god have any grounding in science and are personal [15:18] Psychoanalysing Francis Collins [15:18] do not have any* [15:18] joachim - the moment he acts on it, his beliefs become relevant. Not before then [15:19] i never thought i would disagree with MIGHTY MATT ..: ;) [15:19] Yah... [15:19] Fuck Francis Collins, it's time for a new subject imo [15:19] true [15:19] yea i agree [15:19] I'm starting to think Matt is bending over way too far for this guy. [15:19] codeweaver- i think so too [15:19] Sometimes they gotta just agree to disagree for the moment and work it out later [15:19] For Matt's sake, I hope collins believes in lube [15:19] New Subject! [15:19] i really hate when they get hung up on one little issue for this long [15:20] Rasputin: :D [15:20] They should talk about Free Will. [15:20] Yeah, move on. [15:20] Hardly. He's not defending Collins's positions. He's defending Collins's attitude towards science [15:20] I liked the free will one [15:20] I did too. [15:20] On the other hand, Collins argues that if a "soul" enters the embryo at conception, this would make it difficult to explain identical twins having different souls... [15:20] @spooky - yey! I loved that episode [15:20] Dennis was the man, IMO [15:20] true true [15:20] Given - Collins is a good scientist: What would Collins have to do to prove his is unfit for the post? [15:20] I don't think he explained himself that well [15:21] Dennis to Jeff : "I have no idea what you just said." [15:21] I don't get why Matt thinks morality is a question beyond the ken of science and thus a crack through which Collins can argue such points. [15:21] Trybanpherto: like presidents, we'll judge afterwards [15:21] Denis Jeff and Shilling have been my favorite hosts, I'm pissed Shilling left. [15:21] Moraloid behaviour? [15:21] I mean, certainly science may not have good answers on that yet, but also certainly religion and God does not. [15:22] science doesn't answer, it works [15:22] with working hypotheses [15:22] Well, yes, eventually. [15:22] planes fly [15:22] Hee, Matt said ass. [15:22] There have almost certainly been Christians worse than Collins at the NIH. Collins has just talked more about it, so we have the ability to nitpick his words. I think he'll be just fine, and if he's not we'll bitch then. [15:22] magic carpets don't [15:22] We should all just start spamming NEW TOPIC. [15:22] i think matts opinion ON THIS is contradictory to his STATEMENTS about the BILL MAHER award issue ... [15:22] new [15:22] topic [15:23] Yeah, new topic! [15:23] NEW TOPIC [15:23] well your wrong [15:23] The show is almost over, too. [15:23] NEW TOPIC [15:23] when you say new topic add stay late [15:23] lol [15:23] SpookyElectric: no, we shouldn't. [15:23] SpookyElectric: do it one more time, might help [15:24] so BILL MAHER should get the award matt ... ??? [15:24] liquid light that doesn't make sense [15:24] Bill Maher should be head of NIH. [15:24] Liquidight: could you explain in more detail? [15:24] That should work. [15:24] the qualifications for the award include being an atheist [15:24] maher isnt [15:24] I'm just wondering if anyone else was considered for the NIH. [15:24] That's awfully fine hair splitting. [15:25] the qualifications for nih include being a scientist [15:25] LiquidLight is probably referring to the fact that Maher believes vaccines and other medical treatments are crap [15:25] I know, it was sarcasm. [15:25] and collins is [15:25] There needs to be a sarcasm font. [15:25] and being scientific IS .... ??? [15:25] The award Maher is getting is broader than the NIH. Maher simply doesn't live up to it. [15:26] um, are you saying that a person who is a scientist can have compatmentlized religious views that they do not feel have anything to do with science/ [15:26] can't* [15:26] Didn't the president pick the head of NIH? [15:26] Did they do listener mail in the first 50mins? [15:26] New Topic! [15:26] No. [15:27] No... [15:27] They've covered 2 or 3 topics [15:27] Then lets move on to that [15:27] Exactly, Russell. [15:27] I like the mail [15:27] ok ... thunderf00t vs comfort ... ? [15:27] SpookyElectric, 2 right? [15:27] Kathleen don't get to say much :) [15:27] The C street thing, Bill Maher, and Francis Collins [15:28] A little on the Dark Flow thing as well. [15:28] Right ... [15:28] Come on guys, you're not gonna agree on this? Move on ... [15:28] THOR! [15:29] Good question! [15:29] what is this ... ? matt falling into the FROZEN WATERFALL ... ??? [15:29] I know a person who's a Viking. [15:29] Kathleen, smack them in the face, then ask your question [15:29] I'm proud of that. [15:29] Thor rules, BTW. [15:29] well, thor is supposed to be physical... isn't he? [15:29] This is not going to be one of those episodes I listen to five times [15:29] Loki all the way [15:29] Talk about it later!!!!!!! [15:30] I'm backing Loki. [15:30] Rasputin, yup! [15:30] Tricksy tricksy [15:30] Now I can finally drink my beer! :-) [15:30] its porbably warm by now [15:30] man i can't type today [15:31] Odin ftw [15:32] http://www.crosswalk.com/news/religiontoday/11605811/ [15:32] the np need live callers ... [15:32] For how long have they been on this topic now? [15:32] i still wouldn't fund it -_- [15:32] Did you hear about the honour killings up here in Canada? [15:32] 45mins+ ? [15:32] feels like forever [15:32] collins approves of stem cell research [15:32] Well, alleged honour killings... [15:32] What exactly happened? [15:32] this topic has lasted longer than the last two weeks [15:32] good for collins new topic [15:32] Three daughters and the wife of an Afghani husband were found at the bottom of a canal in a car. [15:33] Matt won [15:33] Na, haven't heard anything about that. [15:33] Matt won in the first 5 minutes actually... [15:33] that's not an honor killing it's an honor massacre [15:33] this is like a discussion between 3 guys 2am in the morning at a bar... [15:33] Russell, that doesn't give you the right to not hire them [15:33] but on the podcast? [15:33] I would hate to be opposite Matt in a debate. [15:33] The 2nd wife, the father/husband, and an 18-year-old son/brother were arrested. [15:34] How many wives does he have? [15:34] just 2? [15:34] Two, but only one officially here. [15:34] That's why we all want Matt to debate Comfort [15:34] ok matt ... you'r the WINNER ... could we go to anything else ... ??? [15:34] Well, they're allowed up to 4... He's half way there... [15:34] Where does the honour come in? [15:34] That's a little like swatting a fly with a Buick, Pombolo. [15:34] At least one of the daughters was going out with someone the father did not approve of. [15:34] That's quite lame. [15:35] Yes, but we could pick over the goo left behind [15:35] shouldn't you kill everyone who knew it happened? [15:35] Is you is, or is you ain't my baby. [15:35] Thats one reason I hate people quoting the ten commandments, no one should ever be commanded to honor their parents. [15:35] Collins reconciles the research through a process called somatic cell nuclear transfer, which creates an embryo artificially, but is also the first step in cloning. [15:35] Who sung that song? [15:35] i mean, it still happened and your still the father/whatever [15:35] shame on you? [15:35] Parents shouldn't be able to influence relationships like that. [15:36] New topic? [15:36] Of course Mat would have to find a way around the Coke Can theory of Comfort's [15:36] You're right, Matt. :-) [15:36] great debate guys! [15:36] move ON [15:36] Yes, Matt - you are sick and twisted.. But in a good way ;) [15:36] We love you anyway, Matt. :D [15:36] Here's one: http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=1851168 "Victim wed in secret: Teenager killed in canal had been forced to end union" [15:36] * ntesla has left #nonprophets [15:37] Actually I think Matt's made his point well. [15:37] Wow, the feed is lagging WAY behind this chatroom [15:37] i like discussions like this [15:37] Yes, the discussion was intense, and that's *good*. [15:37] As long as one isn't close-minded, heated discussions are good. [15:37] best EX-MUSLIM channel on YT: http://www.youtube.com/user/discussislam [15:38] One of the most conservative countries in Eastern Europe has taken a significant step towards embracing same sex marriage. [15:38] The Prime Minister of Albania, one of the last bastions of conservatism following the collapse of the Soviet Bloc, has announced that his party will introduce a Bill legalising same sex marriage. Acknowleding the Bill will be controversial, Sali Berisha says discrimination must become a thing of the past in modern Albania. [15:38] More than a few times I've had to point out to people that being passionate is not synonymous with appeal-to-emotion. [15:38] Albania is a predominantly Muslim country with no openly gay community to speak of. The Bill was drawn up by a group of non-governmental organisations and is likely to have a rough passage in the face of religious communities which have grown in strength since the overthrow of communism almost twenty years ago. [15:38] http://www.gaynz.com/articles/publish/3/article_7751.php [15:39] Wow, go Albania... [15:39] why don't we just criminalize all speech and be done with it? [15:39] were they muslim prior to soviet? [15:40] Yes. [15:40] and they kept their religion? [15:40] That was all Ottoman before Yugoslavia. [15:40] ah [15:40] They kept their religion like the Russian Orthodox did, etc... [15:40] well i'm not going to Ireland anytime soon [15:40] dwharder - I just read it, has anything come out why he killed the sisters? [15:41] Besides, Yugoslavia was not Soviet--they had closer ties to China. Tito was much more liberal than Stalin. [15:41] That's what I said. [15:41] You mean why the brother was in on it? Nothing yet. [15:41] Idiocy has no limits. [15:42] Well they were pissed about the daughter getting married but they killed the sisters to for whatever reason. [15:42] albania wasn't part of soviet, though, was it? [15:42] Sorry, true... [15:42] Sovietbloc [15:42] as a general term, I believe [15:42] I was thinking Kosovo. [15:44] * jimbo has quit IRC (jimbo) [15:44] argument from authority [15:45] And Jesus was a white guy who spoke English [15:45] * LKL has quit IRC (ChatZilla 0.9.85 [Firefox 3.5.1/20090715094852]) [15:45] GOD chose MATT as head for the ACA ... [15:45] With long flowing hair, not a crazy jew fro. [15:45] true [15:45] Excellent show, guys! [15:45] * msm287 has quit IRC (msm287) [15:45] Great show. [15:45] Peace out. [15:45] hope the AE is on ... [15:45] * SpookyElectric has quit IRC (SpookyElectric) [15:45] That was good... [15:45] * Pombolo manically waves [15:45] * CodeWeaver hugs the show. Carefully, cause it has spiky bits. [15:45] * Rasputin has quit IRC (ChatZilla 0.9.85 [Firefox 3.5.1/20090715094852]) [15:46] CodeWeaver: hehe, a bit.. But just pet it and it purr [15:46] * Pombolo has quit IRC (ChatZilla 0.9.85 [Firefox 3.0.11/2009061622]) [15:46] purrs* [15:46] Great show [15:46] Thanks guys, see ya! [15:46] * Aletheia has quit IRC (Aletheia) [15:46] Oh crap D: [15:46] * john has quit IRC (ChatZilla 0.9.85 [Firefox 3.0.12/2009070611]) [15:46] goodbye all - enjoy the rest of the weekend! [15:46] Just came back online [15:46] * K_Nielsen has quit IRC (Blue ... No, yel - aaaargh!) [15:46] * PhilA has quit IRC (PhilA) [15:46] What a timing, huh :P [15:46] Retales: great timing ;) [15:47] * ChristOnIce sets mode: -o ChristOnIce [15:47] * Trybanpherto has quit IRC (ChatZilla 0.9.85 [Firefox 3.5.1/20090715083437]) [15:47] * ChristOnIce has quit IRC (ChristOnIce) [15:47] * kylind has quit IRC (ChatZilla 0.9.85 [Firefox 3.5.1/20090715094852]) [15:47] * xghosthunter has quit IRC (xghosthunter) [15:47] * raynet has quit IRC (raynet) [15:47] Ok...I didn't get to see much chat, hopefully the discussion was enjoyed by someone other than me. [15:47] No worries. :D [15:47] It was intense. [15:47] Gonna get this uploaded and try to get stuff done before tomorrow's show. See ya then! [15:48] * Disconnected Session Close: Sat Aug 01 15:48:04 2009